Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

An Open Letter to Minneapolis Teachers From a Black Educator

A first year NYC educator shares their admiration for the fight put forward by the Minneapolis Public School teachers and their determination to win.

Carmin Maffea

March 24, 2022
Facebook Twitter Share
Luigi Morris/LV

Dear Minneapolis teachers setting the example for us all,

I write this letter in the barest and realest way I feel I can present myself. I am a twenty-six-year-old Black assistant teacher whose Haitian immigrant mother endures daily the agony of arthritis in her hands while caring for patients as a nurse’s assistant; whose Haitian immigrant father works seven days a week for almost twelve hours a day driving a NYC yellow cab. One of the deepest things I share with them, rather than ties of a shared home, is our experience with exploitation.

My parents suffer the same exploitation today as they did when raising me and my three siblings. And I — a degree, a job, and a shattered dream later — am an assistant teacher struggling to make it through the stress of the workday. Even as I pen this letter of admiration now, I feel my heart trembling within the tight walls of my chest. A chest that is so tight from stress and anxiety, I feel it won’t expand despite the depth of my breath. 

As an assistant teacher, this is my first experience teaching in a classroom and every day I am tasked with more than I can handle. I was recently responsible for covering Social Studies for a whole grade of about one hundred students. I was responsible for preparing the lessons, printing material, testing, and grading all the students’ work. This is while I am already responsible for 107 students in another subject.

I initially didn’t know how long I would cover until they eventually told me it would be for two whole months, even though I told them I was suffering and feeling overwhelmed. I couldn’t sleep through the night because the conditions were too awful. Instead of easing me into the workload they used the coverage as an opportunity to evaluate whether they will hire me full-time next year. They later wrote me up for not collecting enough exit tickets by the end of my coverage.

School officials purport our school is a leader in racial equity. However, children in white affluent neighborhoods would never have just one first-year teacher assistant responsible for educating over one hundred students. Our students deserve better.

Many of my coworkers cry on their way to work. Many who drive don’t sleep enough. And a close coworker who regularly suffers from panic attacks due to work stress had one at the school just this week. 

This experience isn’t isolated within my school. I’ve been on panels with teachers from El Paso, Chicago, and Minneapolis and our experiences all have the commonality of being, put bluntly, awful. I have close friends in South America who are also teachers and their schools are dilapidated just as schools are in the hoods of the US. The overcrowded classrooms you guys are taking a vehement stance against, likely look like the classrooms my closest friends were crammed into growing up due to the mass closures of public schools in New York City. 

Our schools are crumbling, our working conditions are terrible, and our students’ experience in school is unworthy of them because of the many years of attacks on education. These attacks killed unions and closed or underfunded public schools. They were delivered by the cold hands and cold smiles of Democratic and Republican politicians alike. 

You are not only openly voicing the pain of educators everywhere so potently it compelled me to write this letter, you are also showing educators and students everywhere that we do not have to be demoralized, that we are not alone, and that we can fight against our abominable working conditions together. You reminded me that my coworkers and I run the school and that without us the school wouldn’t function, that me and my students’ families want the same for the kids — a quality education — and that we can fight tooth and nail, side by side with power that can erupt cities to win the conditions required for kids to have a quality education. Many of those things you guys are fighting for, within the place of the rebirth of a global movement that fought for Black lives. With this struggle, you are continuing that fight for Black lives right now. As you hold the line, just know, you are inspiring educators and workers around the world to fight with the same ferocity. 

I send my admiration, my love, and my solidarity to every striking Minneapolis educator. My experience at work was slowly dwindling my convictions to fight for better conditions. After seeing you fight the behemoth that is the state of public education, my conviction and determination is boundless once again.

Black and proudly, 

Carmin (proud member of Left Voice)

Facebook Twitter Share

Carmin Maffea

Carmin is a revolutionary socialist from New York.

Labor Movement

Several workers hugging in front of a Chipotle Store

The Unionization Wave Continues: Workers In Maine Have Organized the First Chipotle Store in the Country

Workers at an Augusta, Maine Chipotle have formed an independent union: Chipotle United. This is a clear indication that the unionization wave that started with Starbucks and Amazon is only growing stronger.

James Dennis Hoff

June 22, 2022

U.K. Railway Workers Begin Largest Strike in 30 Years

Amid high inflation, tens of thousands of railway and subway workers across the United Kingdom have declared at least three days of work stoppages to demand wage increases and other protections. Transport across much of the region has ground to a halt.

Protester holds a sign that reads "Pro Union, Pro Choice"

Roe Is About to be Overturned: Organize With Your Co-Workers to Fight for Abortion Rights

Roe v. Wade is about to be overturned, marking the biggest defeat of the feminist movement in the past 50 years. We need to organize in rank-and-file committees to mobilize for reproductive rights.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

June 20, 2022

‘It’s Devastating’: NYC Schools Face Enormous Budget Cuts

Left Voice publishes an interview with a teacher at New York City’s MS 839, who has been organizing with his school community against the city’s school budget cuts.

Emma Lee

June 20, 2022


We Need Socialist Feminism. Join Bread & Roses

Faced with reactionary attacks from the Right and increasing economic and political crisis, we urgently need a feminism that fights for all the oppressed and exploited. We need a feminism that harnesses our power as those who make society run to fight for a better future. We need socialist feminism. Join Left Voice in building Bread & Roses today.

Left Voice

June 24, 2022

Unions, Left, and Activist Groups in New York City Organize Coalition and March in Response to the Supreme Court’s Decision to Overturn Abortion Rights

A new coalition of over 30 left groups, rank-and-file workers organizations and unions, and activists including Left Voice, Starbucks workers, teachers, socialist and housing justice organizations, and others have come together to organize a march and rally today in response to the Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade and to protest the attacks on abortion rights by the State and the Right.

Left Voice

June 24, 2022

Supreme Court Overturns Roe v. Wade. Organize, Mobilize and Fight Back.

Join Left Voice and a coalition of unions, left, activist, and reproductive rights organizations for a rally and march in New York City to defend the right to an abortion. Gather at 6:30 pm in Washington Square Park.

Left Voice

June 24, 2022
Members of Trotskyist organization Revolution Permanente at a protest.

Trotskyists in France Are Reconstituting a Fighting Revolutionary Left. There Are Important Lessons for the United States

The Far Left in France, which has grown complacent at best and has crossed the class line at worst, is being resuscitated with revolutionary politics thanks to the efforts of Révolution Permanente — which include launching a new organization. There are lessons for the United States in what has happened in France and in the opportunities to come.

Scott Cooper

June 23, 2022