Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Brazil: Lula’s Imprisonment Was Never About Corruption. Now There is a Smoking Gun.

Chats published by The Intercept show that the judge who imprisoned Presidential candidate Inacio Lula da Silva systematically worked with the prosecution to strengthen their case.

Facebook Twitter Share

Over a year ago, it looked as if Brazil’s next president would be former President Inácio Lula da Silva of the Workers’ Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores, or PT). He was far ahead of any other contender, thanks to Brazil’s working class and poor, who remembered his eight years as president as a time of economic prosperity. It is commonplace to hear Brazilians say “For the first time, we had meat on the table.”

Lula is now in jail, and Jair Bolsonaro, one of the world’s most right-wing leaders, is president.

Sergio Moro was an integral part of this reversal. Trained by the U.S. State Department, Moro led Operation Car Wash (Lava Jato), an anti-corruption investigation used to further the political agenda of a sector of Brazilian and American capitalists.

In 2018, Moro sentenced Lula to nine years and six months in prison, forcing him to leave the Presidential race. Lula was charged with having received an apartment on a São Paulo beach from the OAS construction company in exchange for building contracts, a charge which Lula denies.

On Sunday, The Intercept published a series of private Telegram messages between Moro, then a judge, and Deltan Dallagnol, the prosecutor who oversaw Operation Car Wash. The messages demonstrate that Moro, a supposedly “impartial” judge, worked with Lula’s prosecutor to help him present the strongest case possible against Lula, although, as the messages also demonstrate, both the prosecutor and Moro had doubts about Lula’s guilt.

This complicity between Bolsonaro and the Operation Car Wash judge was evinced by Moro’s appointment as Minister of Justice by the new president. Now, there is further proof that Lula’s imprisonment was politically motivated.

According to The Intercept, private conversations show that Moro mentored the prosecution on how to present the case, even suggesting the order of sentences. In other conversations revealed by The Intercept, different prosecutors discuss how to stop the Folha de São Paulo newspaper from interviewing Lula in prison. According to the prosecutors, the interview could have benefited Fernando Haddad, the PT candidate who replaced Lula in the presidential election.

The Telegram messages published by The Intercept apparently came from the Public Ministry of the city of Curitiba, where the Car Wash case was based. After they were published, the ministry quickly spoke out against the leak, rebuffing the “vile” action of hackers who they say stole data from prosecutors. The ministry does not deny anything that The Intercept published. As journalist Glenn Greenwald points out, this response from the Public Prosecutor’s Office, or lack thereof, confirms that the material is authentic.

Lula’s attorneys have stressed that the leaked documents prove that Moro and the prosecutors had a “political agenda.”

But for most of us, the fact that the imprisonment of Lula was politically motivated is not news. It is part of the same agenda that led to the overthrow of President Dilma Rousseff in the 2016 coup. However, neither the Workers’ Party nor Lula himself denounced this obvious political maneuver. Rather, before turning himself in and going to prison, Lula affirmed his confidence in Brazil’s criminal justice system. This confidence in the system led to the PT’s failure to mobilize its supporters to defend not only its main leader but also the democratic right of millions of Brazilians to vote for whoever they wanted in the elections. Lula’s imprisonment was a blatant act of political repression against the only candidate who could win in the first round in 2018—that is to say, the only one who could beat Bolsonaro.

Operation Car Wash and U.S. Intervention

But Operation Car Wash was not just an operation against Lula and the PT. It began as an investigation into the corruption of large Brazilian companies, the so-called global players, which carry a lot of weight in Brazil and Latin America. They were the primary companies that American businesses wanted to displace in order to expand in Brazil.

This sheds new light on the Wikileaks revelation of a State Department report on a 2009 seminar when a U.S. team trained its pupils—including Brazil’s Federal Police, the judiciary, and the Public Ministry, as well as delegations from Mexico, Costa Rica, Panama, Argentina, Uruguay, and Paraguay—on how to undertake money-laundering investigations. Sergio Moro was among the participants and used these methods in the campaign against Lula.

The Capitalists Want the Working Class to Pay for the Crisis

Rousseff was impeached as the Brazilian economy took a nosedive, and austerity measures were being implemented against the working class. After the coup against Rousseff, her vice president, Michel Temer, took over the presidency. But Temer’s popularity ratings were laughably low: less than 10% approval for much of his presidency, as his own corruption came to light as well. This, coupled with the country’s fragile political and economic situation, prevented Temer from advancing the reforms demanded by Brazilian capitalists and foreign imperialism. So in order to ensure the implementation of the austerity and privatizations favorable to foreign capital, the judiciary, together with the economic and media establishment, aimed to help Bolsonaro become president. Already we see Bolsonaro cozying up to Donald Trump and opening Brazil’s door to foreign investment.

The Intercept’s disclosure is explosive for Brazilian politics. The GDP is shrinking, and unemployment and poverty are skyrocketing. The capitalists want the working class to pay for the crisis with massive austerity measures and cuts. But an enormous movement against education cuts emerged, bringing over a million youth and workers to the streets. Furthermore, there is a general strike called for June 14th against the pension cuts proposed first by Temer and now by Bolsonaro.

Left Voice spoke with Diana Assunção, editor of Esquerda Diario and leader of the MRT. Assunção pointed out that “Esquerda Diario insisted that Operation Lava Jato was a true pro-imperialist operation and the execution of an institutional coup. Under the banner of ‘fighting corruption,’ Moro intended to leave the way open for imperialist capital and its political expression in a ‘proper’ government. The aim of this government was to apply an austerity plan that would attack the working class and the popular sectors, even more than the PT itself had done.”

Assunção declared that now more than ever it is necessary “to demand the immediate release of Lula, though without giving any political support to the PT.” She concluded, “It is impossible to battle the neoliberal adjustments of the Bolsonaro government without the most complete political independence from the reactionary operation Lava Jato and judicial authoritarianism as a whole, which was and is a pillar of the institutional coup and of the neoliberal agenda.”

This article was first published in Spanish on La Izquierda Diario. 

Facebook Twitter Share

Juan Andrés Gallardo

Juan is a journalist from Buenos Aires and the editor of the international section of our Argentinian sister site La Izquierda Diario.


Latin America

Lula Finishes Ahead of Bolsonaro, but the Elections Will Be Decided in the Second Round

Lula and the PT came out on top in the first round of Brazil’s elections, but it’s far from clear that their conciliatory program can stop the Right.

André Barbieri

October 2, 2022

Confronting Bolsonaro and the Far Right Requires Working Class Independence

Socialist candidates Marcello Pablito and Maíra Machado discuss the political situation in Brazil ahead of this Sunday's elections and the challenges for the working class and the oppressed.

Paul Ginestá

October 1, 2022
Woman holds a yellow sign that says "Nueva constitucion" in black text and another person is holding a yellow sign behind her that reads "No violencia clasista"

‘Boric Has Strengthened the Right-Wing Opposition’: Interview with a Chilean Socialist

In Chile, the illusion of winning the battle against neoliberalism in parliament has been shattered. We interviewed Chilean socialist Dauno Totoro about the recent rejection of a proposed constitution and the need to fight for a revolutionary, internationalist, and socialist Left.

Left Voice

September 25, 2022
Chilean president Gabriel Boric

Chileans Reject Proposed Constitution

On Sunday, Chileans overwhelmingly rejected a new proposed constitution. The result reflects both a rightward shift in Chile and disillusionment with President Gabriel Boric.

Otto Fors

September 6, 2022


Vigil in South Korea against femicide (post-it notes on a wall)

Femicide in South Korea: The State and Bosses Are Responsible

The recent murder of a woman who worked for Seoul Metro shows the dangers faced by women workers in Korea. The working class must organize against femicide and sexual harassment in the workplace.

Youngmi Lee

October 5, 2022
Union leaders are joined by community group representatives, elected officials and social activists for a rally in support of unionization efforts by Amazon workers in the state of Alabama on March 21, 2021 in Los Angeles, California. - Workers and organizers are pushing for what would be one of the biggest victories for labor in the United States over the past few decades if successful in the first Amazon warehouse union election in Bessemer, Alabama, where worker's ballots must reach the regional office of the National Labor Relations Board by March 29 to be counted.

‘We Need a Labor Movement That’s a Lot More Militant and Willing to Challenge the Status Quo’: An Interview with Joe Burns

Joe Burns, director of collective bargaining with the CWA-AFA union, discusses his new book, Class Struggle Unionism, and the importance of a militant labor movement.

Left Voice

October 4, 2022
A Pakistani man wades through flood waters carrying a bit bag of produce.

‘It’s Time to Declare War on This Climate-Destroying System!’: Interview with a Pakistani Socialist about the Flood

The flood in Pakistan is one of the most horrific climate events in recent history. A Pakistani socialist describes the consequences of the disaster, as well as the economic crises facing the country.

Maxi Schulz

October 3, 2022
Two men wading through floodwaters with an inundated house in the background.

Water Crises Portend Socialism or Barbarism

Catastrophic floods, droughts, and infrastructure failures highlight the ecological dangers of capitalism, and the urgent need for socialism.

Signý A.

October 1, 2022