Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Ireland and Argentina Won Abortion Rights through Struggle. Protecting Our Rights Here Won’t Be Any Different

Abortion rights are under threat in the United States. As the abortion movements in Ireland and Argentina have shown, the right to free, safe, and legal abortions can only be won through combative action and mass mobilization in the streets.

Facebook Twitter Share
Abortion rights activists wearing green bandana fill the streets.
Photo: Ronaldo Schemidt / AFP - Getty Images

The United States is currently facing the greatest  assault on abortion rights since the Roe v. Wade decision in 1973. A Texas anti-abortion law, which went into effect in October, has criminalized abortions after six weeks of pregnancy — before many people even know they’re pregnant — and incentivized vigilante policing of anyone who seeks or provides an abortion, or even just drives someone to a provider. Soon after, the state of Mississippi imposed a ban on abortions 15 weeks into a pregnancy, which challenges the 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey ruling that established the legality of abortion up to the point of “fetal viability.” 

On December 1, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the Missisipi case and signaled that the new anti-abortion law will be upheld, which would effectively undo the Roe decision by making these “legal” abortions almost impossible to access, and could kickstart a series of “trigger” laws across the country in the 21 states with laws or constitutional amendments banning abortion already on the books. In other words, upholding the Mississippi law would effectively end the federally guaranteed right to an abortion in the United States. The ruling will come in June 2022.

Many have suggested that the new assault on abortion rights results from the absence on the bench of “progressive” judges such as the late Ruth Bader Ginsberg. But the strategy of voting for Democrats to secure a more liberal Supreme Court is a dead end. The Supreme Court is made up of unelected officials that hold the position for life, and are completely unaccountable to anyone, least of all the poor and working class for whom the legal right to an abortion is fundamental. 

There is a way forward, however. Activists in Argentina and Ireland have shown that abortion rights can be won through persistent, combative, and collective action. In Poland, women, students, and workers walked out to protest a near-total ban on abortions imposed in 2020, recognizing that their collective strength, not “progressive” judges, as the only way to secure reproductive rights. That’s precisely how we can protect the right to an abortion in the United States.

Ireland

In 2018, Ireland legalized abortion for the first time. Yet it was not the court system or legislators who were responsible. It was the massive women’s movement that took to the streets and organized combative actions to secure the right to abortion.

Abortion was prohibited by law in Ireland in 1861. More than a hundred years later, the country took the offensive against women even further, codifying that ban with a 1983 constitutional amendment that granted legal personhood to fetuses. Not only did the amendment prohibit terminating a pregnancy, but it even placed legal restrictions on disseminating information about accessing abortions, including censoring British magazines in Ireland that advertised abortion services. Women who attempted to end pregnancy illegally without medical supervision faced 14-year jail sentences. 

The first March for Choice was organized in 2012 and, over the next several years, pro-choice demonstrations grew to tens of thousands of people. The movement was galvanized by the tragic death of a 31-year old dentist named Savita Halappanavar. She had been told by doctors that a miscarriage was imminent, but the state intervened to keep her from terminating the pregnancy. Continuing the pregnancy killed her, and her death became a national symbol of the dangers of denying abortion rights.

On International Women’s Day in 2017, thousands of women in Ireland took part in the “Strike 4 Repeal,” demanding an end to the Eighth Amendment. Participants successfully shut down Dublin for four hours. It was clear that the abortion rights movement was shifting popular opinion. Politicians who for years had defended the anti-choice laws were forced to change their public positions. 

In 2018, the Irish government, under heavy pressure from the movement but still unwilling to legalize abortions itself, called a referendum. The feminist movement organized a massive campaign to vote “Yes” to abortion rights. Several unions were won over to the campaign and declared their support. Tens of thousands of Irish people living abroad, from the United Kingdom to Australia to Tokyo, flew home to cast their votes. The “Yes” vote won by a landslide, with two-thirds of Irish voters supporting the right to choose.

Argentina

Abortion was long considered an untouchable issue in the Latin American country, given the central role played by the Catholic Church in Argentina’s politics. Jorge Mario Bergoglio — known now as Pope Francis — was one of the many leading figures in the church who helped block any relaxation of restrictions on abortion.

But the threads of women’s resistance run deep in Argentina. The feminist movement — with many of its members aligned with Trotskyism — organized some of the first public demonstrations for the right to an abortion and free access to contraceptives in the early 1970s. The movement grew in response to  new limits on birth control imposed by President Juan Péron. Far-Left organizations launched the Frente de Lucha para la Mujer (Front for Women’s Struggles), which demanded not only abortion and contraceptive access but also wages for domestic work, free childcare, and rights for LGBTQ people.

When the military dictatorship took power in 1976, abortion rights were further restricted. But even then the Left refused to sideline its agitation for abortion access in its legal and underground press. 

After the dictatorship ended in 1983, legal provisions regarding abortion were reset to what they had been in 1922:  they were permitted only in cases of rape or if the pregnant person’s health was in danger. Neither the center-Right nor the center-Left governments, including that of the “progressive” Cristina Kirchner — the country’s first woman president, who served from 2007-2015 — lifted the general ban on abortions.

The abortion rights movement began to gain steam in the 1990s and took a leap forward in the 2010s. The new wave of activism was closely tied to the growing movement against femicides in the country; activists rightly highlighted that deaths from clandestine abortions was one more manifestation of the violence facing women in Argentina.

In 2015, 14-year-old Chiara Pae was found buried underneath her boyfriend’s house in Rufino, Argentina. An autopsy revealed her death to be the result of severe beatings to her head and body. This murder, one of countless femicides in the country and across Latin America, sparked the Ni Una Menos (Not One Less) movement. The enormous demonstrations that responded to Pae’s death spanned several countries, including Chile and Uruguay, and gathered 200,000 in Buenos Aires alone.

Following another murder of a young woman in 2016 in the coastal city of Mar del Plata, Ni Una Menos organized a women’s mass strike, the first of its kind in Argentina. Across the country, women walked out of work dressed in mourning. The movement made clear the link between femicide, healthcare, and abortion rights. If people cannot access free, safe, and legal abortions, they are more likely to seek clandestine abortions that can result in death.

A Green Wave, as it came to be known, shook the country in 2018, as hundreds of thousands of women, girls, LGBTQ people, and supporters filled the streets throughout the country, many in green bandanas that became a symbol of the fight for abortion rights. The anti-capitalist Left — the only political force without links to the Church — also played a leading role in the  movement. One of the most visible figures was Myriam Bregman, a human rights lawyer, Trotskyist, and member of the PTS (Workers Party for Socialism); she is now a member of Argentina’s Congress. Socialist feminist groups such as Pan y Rosas (Bread and Roses), built by the PTS, organized thousands of students, workers, and women activists to take to the streets under its purple banners during the years-long fight. 

Abortion rights were finally won in 2020 — a direct result of the country’s mass women’s movement. Several members of Congress aligned with Péronism were forced to reverse their earlier oppostion to abortion, and a new law legalizing abortion passed. While the new law does not go as far as the movement had demanded, it was an important victory achieved only through persistent organizing and massive demonstrations in the streets.

Poland

Last year’s mobilizations in Poland represent some of the most recent mass demonstrations for abortion rights. Poland has long had some of Europe’s strictest laws against the right to an abortion. Of the few abortions that were sanctioned, the vast majority were in cases of fetal defects. 

On October 22, 2020, the new Polish Constitutional Tribunal, a judicial body established to resolve disputes on the constitutionality of the activities of state institutions, decided on a near-total abortion ban, even in cases of fetal defects. Following the court ruling, tens of thousands of Poles gathered in protest. The demonstrators established a democratic council that met and drafted demands, one of which was the resignation of the government. An estimated 400,000 women took to the streets across the country during the days that became known as the Women’s Strike. Activists interrupted masses and defaced churches, and walked off the job and out of classes. 

While the movement has not yet won, it has shifted public opinion. Today, more Poles support abortion rights than ever before. 

The Movement We Need

The successful mobilizations in Ireland and Argentina show how abortion rights can be won and preserved. It won’t happen, though, through the Democratic Party. Democrats have never taken steps to codify Roe into law when they have held both the White House and Congress. In fact, a record number of abortion clinics began to close during the Obama presidency. 

Nor will protecting abortion rights come from the million-dollar nonprofit organizations tied to the Democratic Party, which organize only the occasional symbolic march. These groups and their leaders have failed to stand up for our rights too many times to count. Organizations like Planned Parenthood or NARAL have directed their enormous resources toward electing Democratic politicians — Planned Parenthood contributed $45 million during the 2020 election campaign — rather than organizing a powerful, sustained movement in defense of abortion rights.

Rather than relying on politicians or organizations like these, we need to demonstrate our strength in the streets and through combative actions to secure this critical democratic right. This means drawing inspiration from the brave Irish, Argentinian, and Polish activists, organizing strike actions and shutting down business as usual. It means creating democratic organizations to coordinate struggles around the country, with decisions made by assembly, so that we can keep mobilizations going until abortions are made freely available — and free of cost — to all. 

We have the power to win. Let’s use it.

Facebook Twitter Share

Robert Belano

Robert Belano is a writer and editor for Left Voice. He lives in the Washington, DC area.

Gender & Sexuality

The New York Times Is Wrong: Trans Kids Need Support, Not “Gender Skepticism”

While state legislatures across the country have launched an unprecedented attack on trans youth, the New York Times saw fit to publish a pair of articles calling on liberals to make space for “gender skeptical” ideas among parents. They are wrong. Trans kids need more support, not gender skepticism.

Reba Landers

January 31, 2023
New York Times journalists and other staff protest outside the Times' office in New York on December 8 2022.

Class Struggle Solidarity and the Trans Movement (or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love My Class)

While writers at The New York Times staged a 24-hour walkout on Thursday, some trans people expressed skepticism about showing solidarity for workers at a publication that distributes so much transphobia. A trans socialist explains why queer solidarity with the labor movement is so important, even when workers might not yet be taking up our struggles.

Ezra Brain

December 11, 2022

In a Win for Reproductive Justice, Michigan Voters Reject Abortion Ban

Michigan’s Proposal 3 restores some of Roe’s protections in a mass repudiation of the undemocratic Supreme Court. This is a win for abortion rights, but the movement for reproductive justice must demand more than what Michigan had under Roe.

Lisa Youngs

November 9, 2022

The Antidote to Midterm Despair Is Socialist Feminism

Among feminists, many are driven to the polls by the attacks on reproductive rights and trans youth. But so many go to the polls reluctantly, for lack of another solution. The antidote to midterm despair is socialist feminism.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

November 8, 2022

MOST RECENT

No to NATO Tanks in Ukraine, Let’s Fight the Escalation!

Left Voice and our comrades in Germany issue a joint statement against NATO sending tanks to Ukraine. We call on the working class to organize against this reactionary war which continues to escalate.

Left Voice

January 31, 2023

Higher Ed Strike Fever: This Morning, Temple’s Grad Students Walked off the Job

TUGSA, organizing Temple University’s graduate students, walked out on strike this morning. Winning will take bottom-up organizing from Temple’s unions and undergraduates, shoulder to shoulder with TUGSA on the pickets.

Jason Koslowski

January 31, 2023
Temple University undergraduate students in Philadelphia walking outside a main building.

Temple’s Undergrads Are Taking On the University Bosses

At Temple University, undergraduate students are joining the ranks of higher ed workers who are fighting back.

Jason Koslowski

January 30, 2023
Detroit socialist activist Tristan Taylor at a protest during 2020.

First We Mourn, Then We Organize: A Letter to Weary Black Organizers Who Have Had Enough

Tyre Nichols, and all victims of police brutality, must be mourned. But we can't stop fighting or give in to despair — we have to build an independent political party that clashes with the capitalists physically, politically, and ideologically.

Tristan Taylor

January 29, 2023