Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

On the Ground at Abolition Park: Demonstrators Vote To Stay after City Council Passes Disastrous Budget

After the NYC City Council failed to cut the NYPD by even $1 billion, activists at the City Hall Encampment voted to remain in the space. Police tried to evict them Wednesday morning, but the encampment held strong.

Facebook Twitter Share
Photo: Reed Dunlea

In the first minutes of Wednesday morning, the City Council of New York voted on a pro-cop budget attacking working class and oppressed people. While Mayor de Blasio claimed that the budget defunded the NYPD by $1 billion, it did no such thing. Instead, it cut social services and education and opened the door to thousands of people getting laid off. 

The City Council hardly budged under the pressure of a 7-day encampment in front of City Hall. While the original organizers of the encampment called for defunding the police by $1 billion, the people taking part in the encampment demanded much more: with some going so far as to rename the encampment “Abolition Park,” representing their demands to abolish the police. 

The day of the budget vote arrived on Tuesday, with some activists using the space of the encampment to ask protesters to call or text their city council members. However, when the time of the vote came — after having been delayed by nearly 12 hours — the encampment watched on their phones and on shared makeshift projection screens and booed as the city council votes were tallied. Because that’s all they could do: watch, wait, and boo. The complete lack of democracy of these elected leaders who are not recallable, who answer to no one but the corporate interests that fund them and the interests of the capitalist Democratic Party, was clear. 

As one sector of protesters watched and booed, others used the higher numbers present to expand the encampment, taking over the street and barricading in One Police Plaza. On the side of a court building, someone spray painted “Revolution in our time. Socialism or Barbarism.” This represents a strong trend among protesters: that the time for small reforms (like a small budget cut or slightly more accountability in this or that area) is over.  

Only a few hours later, the encampment engaged in a form of democracy unlike those of the capitalists. An assembly was called to discuss the next steps for the encampment. Over and over, folks stood up in front of the assembly to demand that protesters stay and continue the encampment, arguing that nothing has been won yet and that we should fight for more. Then, the protesters voted, with the overwhelming majority voting to stay in the space. 

A few hours later, hundreds of police in riot gear surrounded the encampment. Some people got arrested. Some people got pepper sprayed. But people remained firm, standing off against the police who brandished their batons. People linked arms, singing, filming, and standing strong together. As both protesters and members of the media filmed, protesters stood almost nose-to-nose with riot cops, refusing to retreat, refusing to concede.

And they held the line. While the police were able to disperse them from the street, the solidarity, numbers, and media coverage meant that the main encampment wasn’t evicted.  

Facebook Twitter Share

Enid Brain

Ezra is a NYC based theatre artist and teacher.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

Tatiana is a former middle school teacher and current Urban Education PhD student at CUNY.

United States

The 9 current U.S. Supreme Court justices.

The Supreme Court Must Be Abolished

The U.S. Supreme Court in a series of rulings this week showed its reactionary character, attacking the democratic rights of workers, youth, and the oppressed.

Tristan Taylor

July 2, 2023

The First Pride Was a Riot, This Pride Is a Strike: Starbucks Workers Shut Down Over 150 Stores

This June, Starbucks implemented a new policy which prevented employees from decorating their stores for Pride. Instead of accepting this hypocrisy from the supposedly queer-friendly corporation, workers at over 150 unionized locations shut things down.

Reba Landers

July 1, 2023

A Marxist Take on the Attack on Trans Rights

Our sister site in France, Révolution Permanente, interviewed Left Voice member Enid Brain about the attack on trans rights in the United States. Enid covers how the crisis of neoliberalism drives the attacks, the role of the Democratic Party, the need for a class independent approach and organization to fight the attacks, and more.

Enid Brain

June 30, 2023
Self-help author Marianne Williamson speaks to the crowd as she launches her 2024 presidential campaign in Washington, Saturday, March 4, 2023. The 70-year-old onetime spiritual adviser to Oprah Winfrey became the first Democrat to formally challenge President Joe Biden for the 2024 nomination.

The Socialist Case against Marianne Williamson

Some leftists argue that we should take Marianne Williamson’s presidential candidacy seriously. But she’s no socialist — and we should not support capitalist parties.

Otto Fors

June 27, 2023

MOST RECENT

Ukraine Is Not Vietnam

What is the class character of the war in Ukraine? Some socialists see it as a war of national liberation against Russian “imperialism,” and so they support the Ukrainian side. But this leads them to align with Western imperialism. Socialists need an independent position.

Nathaniel Flakin

July 1, 2023
On the left, Vladimir Putin. On the right, Wagner Group leader Prigozhin.

The Wagner Group Mutiny Shows Weaknesses in Putin’s Regime

The theatrical mutiny staged by oligarch-turned-warlord Yevgeny Prigozhin, head of the Wagner group, was short-lived but damaging for Putin’s regime.

Claudia Cinatti

June 30, 2023

The Birth of the Homosexual Movement and Socialism in Germany

In this article, we look back at the birth of the homosexual movement in Germany, its ties to socialism, and the lessons of this alliance — in its victories and defeats.

Camille Lupo

June 30, 2023
The Left and Labor Coalition at the NYC Queer Liberation March on June 24, 2023. The banners read "Unite our struggles, build a working-class party for socialism" and "left & labor for trans rights."

Left and Labor March for Trans Rights in New York City

Last weekend, the Left and Labor Coalition marched at the Queer Liberation March, highlighting that attacks on trans rights are an attack on workers' rights.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

June 29, 2023