Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Right-Wing Coalition Wins Italian Elections amid Record-Low Turnout

Amid record-low turnout, Italy’s right-wing coalition won in the country’s snap election this weekend. Ultra-right-wing politician Giorgia Meloni is now set to be the new prime minister. But forming a stable government that lasts five years will be difficult.

Giacomo Turci

September 27, 2022
Facebook Twitter Share
Matteo Salvini, Silvio Berlusconi and Giorgia Meloni at the centre-right coalition's closing rally in Italy.

The final results of the Italian elections show a victory for the right-wing coalition, led by the ultra-right-wing Fratelli d’Italia (Brothers of Italy), headed by their candidate, Giorgia Meloni. But the real winner is abstentionism, which in this election reached a historic 36 percent. According to a common maxim, “What is useful to win an election is not useful to govern afterward.” Thus, a key question is how the winning coalition’s reactionary discourse will be transformed in the new administration.

Results: The Right Wing and Abstentionism Win

The vote count for the Italian parliamentary elections ended early Monday afternoon. From the first polls published Sunday night after the polls closed, the surveys published in the final weeks of election campaign were confirmed: the right-wing coalition won with a wide margin over the center Left, with Meloni’s Fratelli d’Italia garnering the highest share of votes.

The winning coalition got close to 44 percent of the vote, with the Fratelli d’Italia at 26 percent, Mateo Salvini’s right-wing Lega below 9 percent, Silvio Berlusconi’s Forza Italia just above 8 percent, and the minor center allies at almost 1 percent.

The center-left coalition was defeated by almost 20 points, earning around 26 percent of the vote, with the Partido Democratico at 19 percent, the Greens-Left at 3.6 percent, +Europa with 2.8 percent, and Impegno Civico at 0.6 percent. The populist Five Star Movement party, led by former prime minister Giuseppe Conte, confirmed its recovery after last summer’s slump, picking up more than 15 percent of the vote.

For its part, abstention rose from just over 28 percent in 2018 to 36 percent, the highest percentage in the history of parliamentary elections in Italy. In fact, turnout did not exceed 60 percent in any of the southern regions. This confirms the great disconnect between the “ruling” parties, the institutions, and the masses, especially among the youth (where the abstention rate is close to 50 percent) and in the South.

The Right Wing in Government: Perspectives and Contradictions of a Reactionary Nationalist Discourse

Fratelli d’Italia’s winning bet was to openly claim a Catholic-nationalist profile in clear opposition to the Mario Draghi government, which fell in July, and to channel part of Italy’s social discontent. The results of Sunday’s election show that a majority of people reject the parties that had declared themselves full supporters of the “Draghi agenda,” including both the liberal Left and the center Left.

The enthusiastic campaign statements of Meloni, Salvini, and their candidates were the counterpoint to EU Commission president Ursula Von Der Leyen’s ambiguous yet authoritative statement: “If things go in a difficult direction [in Italy] — and I’ve spoken about Hungary and Poland — we have the tools.” Von Der Leyen was referring to statements, threats, and sanctions against those countries with “illiberal” governments that do not vote according to “European values.” The statement indicates the kind of “democratic” attitude with which European centrist liberals confront nationalist right-wingers.

At a time when the European Union is marked by different, if not conflicting, approaches to the geopolitical situation, the war in Ukraine, and the bloc’s more or less subordinated relationship to the U.S. and NATO, the triumph of a reactionary opposition party like Fratelli d’Italia is a factor of instability that restores a small amount of hope to the pro-Putin front. This was even recognized by the Russian media, which claims that Italy could become a new thorn in the side of the European Union.

It’s probably more reasonable, however, to say that full adherence to the EU framework and NATO and U.S. interference in Italian politics will be the thorn in the side of a government led by two parties, Fratelli d’Italia and Lega, which have centered a sovereigntist, anti-European and geopolitical revisionist rhetoric, as opposed to the liberal pro-European approach of Forza Italia and its Christian Democrat allies.

Yet electoral rallies are one thing; actual commitments to a pro-NATO and anti-Russian line are quite another. The latter have been the premise of the common program of the center Right, and they will cause profound government crises if seriously questioned by Meloni and Salvini. As for the national economy, the desire to be a “respectable” right wing — neither openly fascist nor too subversive with respect to the EU, NATO, and other strong powers — will force Meloni to face a public debt that has exceeded 150 percent of the GDP. It will be difficult to find money for new expansive policies without again cutting spending on infrastructure and on the welfare state, and without again attacking the working class, as the capitalists keep demanding.

Over the next few days, the composition of parliament will be solidified, and the government will establish who will occupy the different institutional positions, starting with that of prime minister. The right-wing victory, which has a majority but less than two-thirds of parliamentary seats, will make it difficult both to change the constitution in an authoritarian-presidential direction, as Meloni had thought about doing, and to form a government without the mediation of the rest of the state apparatus and pressure from the EU bureaucracy.

What’s clear is that the policies of the previous Draghi government, and therefore also of the center Left, have paved the way for the rise of the right wing, without constituting any substantial alternative in terms of rights, conditions of the working class and the poor, repression, nationalism, and militarism.

It is still unclear, however, where the right-wing government will begin its attacks. These attacks run the risk of jeopardizing the coalition’s already-minority consensus in society and amid the working class and poor, given the record-low turnout. While Meloni claims to champion these groups and “govern for everyone,” she won with the votes of the most intolerant and reactionary Catholics. Creating a stable government that will last five years will be very difficult, despite this clear electoral victory.

Despite the declarations of harsh opposition issued by Enrico Letta of the Democratic Party and by Conte, it is clear that the social opposition to this reactionary government will have to be built without the help of the other parliamentary parties. This opposition must work to overcome the crisis that the policies of the old (and new) reformist currents have generated.

An excellent response, in this sense, is that of the students of Manzoni high school in Milan, who on Monday occupied the student center to hold a plenary assembly to discuss the situation and what policies to demand in their fight against the new government. These kinds of actions help show the way forward for the working class at this moment.

First Published in Spanish on September 24 in La Izquierda Diario.

Translation by Molly Rosenzweig

Facebook Twitter Share

Giacomo Turci

Giacomo is a journalist from Rome and editor of our Italian sister site La Voce delle Lotte.


Tracking, Deportations, Internment: European Countries Go on the Hunt for Migrants

On May 10, German chancellor Olaf Scholz strengthened Germany’s anti-migrant policy. This means more deportations, border patrol reinforcements, and economic agreements with sending countries. The new policy is being deployed throughout Europe.

Leo Stella

May 25, 2023
People in Berlin demonstrating on the 75th anniversary of the Nakhba.

Berlin Police Attack Jews and Palestinians Commemorating the Nakba

On the 75th anniversary of the Nakba, the Berlin police banned all Palestinian demonstrations, and broke up a demonstration of Jewish Berliners in solidarity with Palestinians.

Nathaniel Flakin

May 22, 2023

In France, There is No Return to Normal for Macron

Anger of the French people at Macron's pension reform is far from extinguished, despite moves by the Inter-Union bureaucracy which weakened the movement.

Juan Chingo

May 20, 2023

The French Union Bureaucracy Tries to Bury the Movement Against the Pension Reform by Resuming “Social Dialogue”

After historic May 1st protests, the Inter-Union announced the following day that the next mobilization will take place on Tuesday, June 6. This distant date appears only to be conceived of as a way to pressure the National Assembly, which continues its strategy of defeat and prepares to bury the movement.

Nathan Erderof

May 12, 2023


US troops at a southern border wall, setting up barbed wire.

Sending Troops to Texas, Republicans Escalate the Bipartisan War on Migrants

Republican governors are sending their states’ soldiers and police to the already heavily militarized southern border to escalate their war on migrants.

Molly Rosenzweig

June 9, 2023

A Neurodivergent Case for Abolitionism

An autistic member of Denver Communists explains why neurodivergent liberation is bound up with the fight to abolish the police and build a socialist system.

Robin Forrester

June 6, 2023
Five young people stand in front of a car in a dessert in a scene from the movie "How to Blow Up a Pipeline."

A New Film Shows How to Blow Up a Pipeline — But Would That Save The Planet?

The new film based on Andreas Malm’s book offers lots of fun action — but very individualistic politics.

Nathaniel Flakin

June 6, 2023
Florida governor Ron DeSantis announcing his bid for the 2024 presidency in front of a big US flag.

Ron DeSantis Is a Reactionary Monster, but the Working Class Can Defeat Him

Far-right Florida governor Ron DeSantis launched his presidential bid for 2024 last month, reflecting some Republicans’ desire to move beyond Trump. The working class can defeat him.

Molly Rosenzweig

June 6, 2023