Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

The Odyssey of Trans Women Trying to Flee Ukraine

Since the beginning of the war, the Ukrainian authorities have barred trans women from leaving the country. Laws in Ukraine are restrictive when it comes to accessing documents with the correct gender identity, and the war has further exacerbated the discrimination suffered by LGBTQ+ people.

Pablo Herón

April 13, 2022
Facebook Twitter Share
Alessio Mamo/The Guardian

At the start of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Zi Faámelu, a 31-year-old trans woman, tried to flee the country, but the Ukrainian authorities would not allow it. The reason? Her identification documents list her gender as male, and Ukraine’s wartime law forbids men aged 18 to 60 from leaving the country. Since the war began, more than 4 million people, mainly women and children, have fled.

Faámelu’s story was shared in the media, and her plight was repudiated as an example of anti-trans discrimination. Ukraine is one of many countries that requires trans people to receive a psychiatric diagnosis and irreversible surgical intervention in order to access identification documents with the correct gender marker. Many countries in Europe continue to pathologize trans identities, which ultimately sustains the stigmatization of trans people. Before 2017, Ukrainian law required that trans people be admitted to a mental health facility to begin the process of changing their personal documents.

All these requirements pose a huge obstacle for thousands of Ukrainian trans people who are seeking refuge. Faámelu was able to flee to Romania by crossing a reservoir, a difficult and dangerous task that required her to swim upstream. “I knew that this was my last chance for survival, and I had to do something like this very quickly,” Faámelu shared with ABC News. The trek was exhausting, she said, and she almost drowned, but “somehow I got to the other side.” She left everything behind in Ukraine, carrying only her passport wrapped in a bag. The treatment she received at the border was similar to what she faced in Ukraine.

Another case that resonated in recent weeks was that of Judis, publicized by the Guardian, who was discriminated against by Ukrainian border guards. Her birth certificate identifies her as a woman, so even on paper she meets the legal requirements to be able to leave the country. But when she arrived at the border checkpoint, she was taken to a room and physically examined.

“Ukrainian border guards undress you and touch you everywhere,” she said, adding, “You can see on their faces they’re wondering ‘what are you?’ like you’re some kind of animal or something.” The guards prevented Judis from crossing the border to Poland and told her, “You’re a guy, so get the hell out of here,” and that she “should be grateful they didn’t call the police,” even though she has a legally valid document that states that she is female.

Alice, 24, recounted experiencing the same situation with her partner, who is nonbinary, in front of three guards. “They told us to take off our jackets. They checked our hands, arms, they checked my neck to see if I had an Adam’s apple.” Another problem she addressed is that she and her partner are running out of hormones due to pharmacy closures, which “is extremely harmful to your health,” especially when done suddenly, she said.

LGBTQ+ advocacy organizations warn that the situation trans women are facing is “very difficult.” Igor Medvid from the HPLGBT, an NGO based in Ukraine, shared that even before the war “the LGBTQ+ community felt marginalized and discriminated against.”

In Ukraine there is no equal marriage law, which also leads to other problems, such as the one reported by Olha Raiter, who traveled to Berlin with her ex-partner Uliana and their seven-month-old son. “We are all discriminated against in Ukraine because we cannot get the same rights. We have Damien together, but officially, she’s nobody to him, even if she’s a mother the same as me … and she was there from the very beginning and she was there when I was delivering him. But she still, according to Ukrainian law … she’s nobody.”

In Ukraine, the Christian Orthodox Church, which considers homosexuality a sin, is a powerful and influential institution. This also the case in Russia, where Putin has been systematically persecuting LGBTIQ+ people for years through anti-gay propaganda laws. Likewise in the United States, the ultraconservative Right has been systematically stripping away the rights of LGBTQ+ people, especially trans youth, and strengthening criminalization of identities.

The war between Russia and Ukraine shook up the international chessboard, evidencing Putin’s reactionary interests and the warlike policy of NATO (the United States and the European Union), with Germany approving a historic military budget.

After a month of conflict, complaints continue to emerge in Ukraine about the government’s refusal to let transgender people leave the country. Their fight for their basic rights — not to be discriminated against because of their gender identity — deserves to be heard.

Originally published in La Izquierda Diario.

Translation by Allison Noel.

Facebook Twitter Share

Europe

United Kingdom: Is a Summer of Discontent on the Horizon?

Workers in the UK are bearing the brunt of the government’s response to rising inflation and slow economic growth. But they’re fighting back, with many talking about a “summer of discontent”.

Alejandra Ríos

June 22, 2022

French Election Results Point to a Political Crisis and Tremendous Instability

Everyone expected a defeat for President Macron in the second round of France’s elections for the National Assembly on June 19, but the results were far worse than any forecast. This opens a major political crisis and begins an explosive five-year term for the president.

French Trotskyist worker Anasse Kazib holds a megaphone and speaks to a crowd at a protest

Call: ‘For the Building of a New Revolutionary Organization in France’

Delegates at a national conference held in France on June 4 and 5 concluded their discussions and deliberations by issuing this call for the building of a new revolutionary organization in the country. The new organization aims to take up the mantle of the Far Left that has been undermined by a liquidationist perspective and a refusal to engage in the struggles of the working class and most oppressed in France.

French Activists Launch the Process to Create a New Revolutionary Organization

At a national conference in Paris on June 4 and 5, 100 delegates came together to begin building a revolutionary organization that can meet the challenges of the coming period and beyond.

Paul Morao

June 14, 2022

MOST RECENT

Several workers hugging in front of a Chipotle Store

The Unionization Wave Continues: Workers In Maine Have Organized the First Chipotle Store in the Country

Workers at an Augusta, Maine Chipotle have formed an independent union: Chipotle United. This is a clear indication that the unionization wave that started with Starbucks and Amazon is only growing stronger.

James Dennis Hoff

June 22, 2022

You Can’t ‘Green’ the Military (You Have to Fight It)

The armed forces of state violence are "going green", but they're no friends of the environment. We need an internationalist climate movement that's strongly opposed to militaries, police, prisons, and borders.

B.C. Daurelle

June 22, 2022

U.K. Railway Workers Begin Largest Strike in 30 Years

Amid high inflation, tens of thousands of railway and subway workers across the United Kingdom have declared at least three days of work stoppages to demand wage increases and other protections. Transport across much of the region has ground to a halt.

AMLO’s Dilemma and the Limits of the Pink Tide

It is essential to establish a clear definition of class character to understand AMLO’s government, taking into consideration the particular characteristics of its “progressivism” in its relationship with the mass movement and capital. Otherwise, one could lose one’s way in implementing socialist and revolutionary politics that genuinely express the historical interest of the oppressed and exploited.

Pablo Oprinari

June 21, 2022