Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

The Rittenhouse Verdict Is Green Light for Right-Wing Vigilantism. The Left Must Respond

The jury’s verdict in the Kyle Rittenhouse trial is a devastating injustice, and a dangerous precedent that will open the door for more right-wing reactionary violence against the Left. To defeat the Right, we must unite our struggles.

James Dennis Hoff

November 20, 2021
Facebook Twitter Share

On August 25 of last year, 17-year-old Kyle Rittenhouse, a white teenager from Antioch, Illinois, armed himself with what he claims was a police-issued bulletproof vest and AR-15 military rifle, and headed to the city of Kenosha, Wisconsin, where protests against the recent police shooting of a Black man, Jacob Blake, were planned for that evening. Rittenhouse claims he went to Kenosha to assist the police and protect private property from looters and rioters — a strange pastime for a teenage boy — but by the end of the evening he had shot and killed two unarmed protesters, and wounded a third. Afterwards, he fled the city, walking directly past several police officers before getting into his car and driving away from the scene of the crime. 

Rittenhouse’s actions, from beginning to end, showed a planned and malicious intention to intimidate and possibly harm peaceful Black Lives Matter protesters, and a blatant disregard for human life when he opened fire in not one but two separate incidents that evening. Rittenhouse says that he feared for his safety, but he was the one with the loaded semi-automatic rifle and the bulletproof vest. He was the one who drove half an hour from his home to play policeman at a protest march which he did not support. He was the one fraternizing with members of the same police department which had just shot Jacob Blake, and he was the one standing with several other armed men who had come to Kenosha in full military gear for the same reasons that he had. These murders, in other words, were not an act of self-defense, as he claims, but a planned act of right wing reactionary political violence. One with deadly — and now possibly significantly political — consequences. 

Yesterday, after a two-week trial, Kyle Rittenhouse was found not guilty, by an almost exclusively white jury. In fact, of the 20 jurors seated, only one was a person of color — a Black person — and it is unclear whether they were even able to cast a vote in the deliberations or whether they were an alternate. However, the case was in the bag long before the jury heard the closing arguments. As we reported not long after the jury was seated, Judge Bruce Schroeder, who oversaw the trial, had gone out of his way to influence and bias the jury in the defendant’s favor. The most egregious examples of this included refusing to allow video evidence of Rittenhouse stating that he wanted to kill protesters to be presented to the jury, and barring the prosecution from referring to the people that Rittenhouse had killed as victims. The judge simultaneously argued that calling them rioters and looters would be acceptable if the defense could prove that they had participated in such activities.

While it seemed clear almost from the start that Rittenhouse would walk, it is worth noting that the jury not only found him not guilty of the murders which he had so clearly committed, but acquitted him of all charges. In fact, the judge had already dismissed several of the charges, including possession of a firearm by a minor, even before the jury was allowed to deliberate. It goes without saying that if Kyle Rittenhouse had been Black, and had been found carrying an illegal firearm, he would not only have been charged, but would likely now be dead or in jail. That’s exactly what happened to twelve year old Tamir Rice, a Black child, who had a toy gun on a playground. The police shot him on arrival and then arrested his sister who rushed to his side as he died.

And this is what is perhaps most terrifying about this verdict. The message sent by this jury and by Judge Schroeder is being heard loud and clear across the country: “If you’re white and conservative, don’t worry, we’ve got your back. If you want to arm yourselves with military grade weapons and patrol the streets of your city or of any nearby city you like, intimidating poor people, people of color, or their supporters, go for it! And if you ‘accidentally’ kill a few, no sweat, we’ll make sure you get off scot-t free.” 

But it gets worse. Rittenhouse isn’t only getting away with murder — he and his family are profiting from it. Since his arrest, he has managed to amass hundreds of thousands of dollars for his defense fund from conservative individuals and groups, including police officers from across the country. And just yesterday, almost immediately after the trial verdict was announced, Rittenhouse received an offer for an internship from Trumpist North Carolina Congressperson Madison Cawthorn, who told his supporters this trial proves that they have a right to defend themselves and that they should “be armed, be dangerous, and be moral.” This clear celebration of and incitement to violence is consistent with an increasingly polarized and militant reactionary conservatism that thrived under Donald Trump, who also congratulated Rittenhouse after the verdict, and remains a serious force in American politics.

The Capitol riots of January 6 were at once the high point of right-wing reaction and the beginning of its political decline. But the period that has followed has also been marked by a strong defense of the conservative institutions of the state, particularly by the Democratic Party and its strategic allies in the unions and social movements. Having already co-opted the Black Lives Matter movement into the electoral process, and convinced millions to leave the streets, to give up organizing among themselves, and prepare for the ballot box, the Democratic Party and the state in all its forms are now acting to delegitimize and destroy it completely. 

You might be interested in: Biden’s Task: Restore U.S. Institutions and Get Back to the Business of Global Domination

And in many ways this verdict really was a repudiation by the state of the Black Lives Matter movement. President Biden’s response to the decision is a perfect example of this. When asked about the verdict by reporters, Biden responded without sympathy or regret, stating simply: “I stand by the jury’s conclusions. The jury system works and we have to abide by it.” This is a significant but unsurprising departure from his campaign trail comments about Rittenhouse, linking him to former President Trump and to white supremacists. By affirming the legitimacy of this illegitimate verdict, Biden is attempting to create further support for the institutions of the state against the political unrest and polarization of the past period. If this requires tossing Black Lives Matter under the bus, he seems more than willing to do so.  

All of this shows that the Democratic Party is not and never has been on the side of racial equality, and we cannot rely upon them to take even the most basic stand against the systemic racism that is fed by, and in turn feeds, white supremacy. In order to defeat the Right, we will have to organize outside the party establishment. This means building, radicalizing, and linking up the organizations of the working class, from the labor unions to movements like Black Lives Matter. It means taking these struggles into our workplaces and using working-class methods such as work actions, strikes, and mass strikes to defeat the Right with the power of our numbers. But more broadly, it also means creating a party of our own capable of building, growing, and leading these struggles to bring about an ultimate break with the institutions of the capitalist state. 

Facebook Twitter Share

James Dennis Hoff

James Dennis Hoff is a writer, educator, labor activist, and member of the Left Voice editorial board. He teaches at The City University of New York.

United States

Let This Radicalize You

The Rittenhouse Verdict was outrageous, but we can’t allow ourselves to fall into despair. We need to take radical conclusions from what happened.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

November 21, 2021
Three white men — Travis McMichael, his father Gregory McMichael, and their friend William “Roddie” Bryan — wearing suits at their trial for the murder of Ahmaud Arbery.

Acquittal of Ahmaud Arbery’s Killers Could Further Embolden Far-Right Vigilantes

The trial of Ahmaud Arbery’s killers comes right on the heels of the Rittenhouse trial. A not guilty verdict would be an injustice and could further embolden far-right vigilante violence.

Sam Carliner

November 21, 2021
A photo of Kyle Rittenhouse, a white man that is turned to the side, wearing a suit.

“We run this society and we can shut it down”: Reflections on the Rittenhouse Trial

The Rittenhouse verdict is an indictment of the racist capitalist system. We can neither rely on the capitalist Democratic party to help us, nor can we afford to get stuck in a vicious cycle of mutual aid efforts that is entrenched in a constant state of responding to capitalist crises. To rid ourselves of this racist capitalist system, we must come together and shut it down.

Adnan Ahmed

November 21, 2021

Native Occupation of Alcatraz Island Began on This Day in 1969

Today marks the 52nd anniversary of the start of what would become a year-and-a-half-long occupation of Alcatraz Island in San Francisco Bay in 1969 by 89 Native Americans and their supporters. It was a remarkable demonstration of Indigenous resistance self-organization and helped launch a broader struggle.

Emma Lee

November 20, 2021

MOST RECENT

The Far Right and the Reformist Left Will Face Off in Chile’s Presidential Elections

In the first round of presidential elections in Chile, the far-right politician José Antonio Kast won 28 percent. The 35-year-old former student leader Gabriel Boric reached 25 percent. The two main traditional parties did not reach a runoff. Trotskyists got 50,000 votes.

Nathaniel Flakin

November 22, 2021
IATSE members marching, carrying a banner that reads "The Union Behind Entertainment"

“We Feel Angry, We Feel Unheard”: IATSE Workers Speak Out on the Betrayal of Their Leadership

Left Voice reached out to IATSE workers and asked for their thoughts on the newly ratified contract. Despite an overwhelming vote to strike and a majority “no” vote, union bureaucracy and undemocratic voting rules betrayed the rank-and-file worker’s demands for better working conditions.

Left Voice

November 22, 2021
Image of person in a white medical coat holding a stethoscope in their left hand and crossing their arms.

The Hypocritical Oath: Medical Residency Trains Physicians to Be Tools for Capitalism

Residency training often claims to focus on training effective physicians. In reality, it’s an intricately designed conditioning process to train physicians to be tools for profit maximization. In order to be truly "effective" physicians, residents, in solidarity with other healthcare workers, must organize to challenge the systems that lead to suffering and illness both in health care and around the globe.

Mike Pappas

November 21, 2021

Education Workers Must Stand in Solidarity with Trans Rights

Today is Trans Day of Remembrance in the midst of a nationwide attack on trans rights in schools. Now more than ever, education workers must stand in solidarity with the rights of trans students.

Emma Lee

November 20, 2021