Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Trotskyist Legislators in Argentina Under Attack for Their Opposition to Zionism

After an initial mistaken vote, the three legislators from the Workers Left Front — Unity (FIT-U) in the city parliament of Buenos Aires came out strongly against a resolution that implicitly equated anti-Zionism with antisemitism. They are now under attack by Zionist organizations.

Nathaniel Flakin

July 24, 2020
Facebook Twitter Share
Myriam Bregman, wearing a red shirt and gray blazer, holds a microphone while raising her fist to the sky. Several other people stand behind her in similar poses. They are outside, and it is night.
Myriam Bergman of the PTS (center) and Gabriel Solano of the PO (left), two of the three Trotskyist legislators in the parliament of Buenos Aires

On Thursday, June 18, the parliament of the City of Buenos Aires voted on a resolution against antisemitism. Socialists have always been on the front lines in the struggle against antisemitism. But this resolution included a definition of antisemitism from the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA). This brief definition might sound vague but unobjectionable — experts have called it “bewilderingly imprecise.”

Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities.

The definition contains an implication: “Jewish community institutions” could hypothetically include the Zionist state in Palestine. Therefore, any opposition to this colonial state — that expels and occupies the Palestinian people while defending the interests of imperialism in the region — could be called antisemitic. The IHRA includes 11 “examples” of supposed antisemitism — and of these, seven relate directly to Israel.

The resolution presented to the parliament did not include these examples, or make any mention of Zionism or the Israeli state. The legislature had been given a packet of almost 100 resolutions on a Wednesday evening, and they had to vote on it on Thursday evening. In a first vote, the three Trotskyist legislators from the Workers Left Front — Unity (FIT-U) — Myriam Bregman and Alejandrina Barry of the PTS, and Gabriel Solano of the PO — voted in favor of the resolution in the belief that it was a general denunciation of antisemitism. The parliament voted on almost 100 resolutions with no deliberation or debate.

Correcting the Vote

The comrades corrected their error with a joint declaration, reaffirming what has always been the FIT’s position since its founding: uncompromising revolutionary opposition to the Zionist state.

The FIT-U — which is composed of four Trotskyist parties, namely PTS, PO, IS, and MST — has always been absolutely clear in its support for the struggle of the Palestinian people. The front’s 20-point manifesto from 2019, for example, includes the point: “Support for the heroic Palestinian people. Down with the Zionist occupation of Palestine.”

The FIT-U has criticized the Argentinian government of Alberto Fernández, whose first foreign trip was to Israel to meet the war criminal Benjamin Netanyahu, in the midst of his push to annex further Palestinian territories in the West Bank. This government, which is from the center-left, claims to support human rights, and yet gives support to a brutal occupation regime. As the FIT-U legislators point out in their statement:

We carry out a fight to the death against antisemitism, but always on the basis of denouncing Zionism and the state of Israel, which is based on genocide and the theft of the lands and property of the Palestinian people. Our principled position has been expressed with our active participation in demonstrations in front of the Israeli Embassy in Argentina.

The legislators called on the secretary of the parliament to correct the voting record. This was done: All three FIT-U representatives votes were subsequently regarded as negative.

Zionist Attack

The very next day, the Zionist Organization of Argentina (OSA) published a statement announcing that it would open legal proceedings against the Trotskyist legislators. This is the logic of the campaign claiming that anti-Zionism is antisemitism: anyone who even questions the definition is smeared as an antisemite.

The OSA statement refers to the Workers Left Front as “deplorable”. They refer to the legislators’ “recognized anti-Israeli and anti-Zionist track record,” and claim that the government’s adoption of the IHRA definition “now gives us a new weapon to take anyone to court who (…) expresses hatred (…) against Zionism as a movement of liberation and self-determination of the Jewish people and against Israel as a Jewish state.”

The legislators, in a new declaration, point out that this is an attack on basic democratic rights such as the freedom of expression — especially for elected members of parliament, who must be able to express their opinions without fear of judicial persecution. This legal norm would allow criticism of any political-ideological movement or any state — except for that of Israel. They reaffirm their unwavering support for the struggle against antisemitism, and continue to denounce the government cover-up of the terrorist attack against the Jewish cultural center AMIA in Buenos Aires in 1993. But this in no way diminishes their condemnation of the crimes of the Israel state, or their support for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination. The call for a single, socialist Palestinian state in which Arabs and Jews can live together in peace.

International Ramifications

The legislators have received support from the International Antizionist Jewish Network in Argentina and the Encuentro Memoria, Verdad y Justicia, the organization that defends the memories of the 30,000 victims of Argentina’s military dictatorship. They met with Husni M.A. Abdel Wahed, the Palestinian ambassador in Argentina, who reacted positively to the corrected vote and recognized the FIT-U’s consistent support for the Palestinian struggle. The entire socialist Left in Argentina, as far as we are aware, has committed to defending the legislators against the Zionist attacks. They deserve support from the international Left as well.

The IHRA definition has been used all over the world, from national parliaments to student associations, to smear the Left. This was most famously used to attack Jeremy Corbyn, the former head of the UK Labour Party who was wildly popular among the youth for his ambitious program of reforms. It was also used in the German Left Party Die LINKE, in order to silence the party’s left wing which expresses solidarity with Palestinians (while the party leadership enthusiastically supports Zionism). In both these cases, the maneuver was successful: Jeremy Corbyn conceded to the pressure and let many of his supporters be expelled from parliament for supposed “antisemitism.” The left-wing deputies from Die LINKE, for their part, left the room during a vote on a resolution condemning even the most basic support for Palestinian rights so that they would vote neither in favor nor against. 

The FIT-U has now introduced a bill into the city parliament calling for the chamber to reject antisemitism while also rejecting the false equivalency between anti-Zionism and antisemitism. This is a bill that the Left internationally should support.

For Reference

For a more thorough example of our position on Palestine, we refer to the Manifesto for a Movement for a Revolutionary Socialist International that we published in 2013:

The struggle of the Palestinian people against the oppression of the zionist state is inseparable from the uprisings in the Arab world. As revolutionaries, we defend the right of the Palestinian people to the national self-determination that they have been denied by imperialism and zionism. Israel treats the minority Arab-Israelis as second class citizens and strongly opposes the right of the Palestinian refugees to return to their lands since these would objectively question the exclusively Jewish character of the state.

This is why we defend the right of return for all Palestinian refugees who were expelled from their land by the Zionist colonisation, and we condemn the military occupation in the West Bank and the expansion of Israeli settlements. We are against the false hope of the two-state solution and the reactionary strategy of the Islamic leaderships, who aim to establish a theocratic state. We’re fighting for the dismantling of the Israeli state as a pro-imperialist and colonial enclave, and for a single Palestinian state that includes all of the historic territory, for a workers’ and socialist Palestine where Arabs and Jews can live in peace.

Facebook Twitter Share

Nathaniel Flakin

Nathaniel is a freelance journalist and historian from Berlin. He is on the editorial board of Left Voice and our German sister site Klasse Gegen Klasse. Nathaniel, also known by the nickname Wladek, has written a biography of Martin Monath, a Trotskyist resistance fighter in France during World War II, which has appeared in German, in English, and in French. He is on the autism spectrum.

Instagram

Latin America

Protests in Colombia Spur Government to Hunt Down Youth

In the aftermath of the 2021 “National Strike” in Colombia, the Duque government is treating youth like terrorists and has launched a series of murders, disappearances, and prosecutions.

Begonia D

December 31, 2021
Protesters Holding banner that reads "Megamineria=Muerte"

Labor Unions, Environmentalists, and Indigenous People Unite to Defeat Mining Interests in Argentina

A zoning law would have opened up the southern Argentinian province of Chubut to large-scale mining by multinational corporations. But the law was defeated in just five days by an alliance of environmentalists, workers, youth, and indigenous people. Their fight points the way forward for other movements around the world.

Marisela Trevin

December 27, 2021

As Millions in Chile Hope for Change, Boric Promises Moderation

Hundreds of thousands of people went into the streets of Santiago to cheer the election of Gabriel Boric. Many are hoping for an end of neoliberalism. But Boric and his party were instrumental in pacifying the popular rebellion that began in October 2019.

Nathaniel Flakin

December 22, 2021
President elect Gabriel Boric of the Social Convergence party and Republican Party candidate José Antonio Kast pose before a presidential debate in Santiago, Chile, on Dec. 13.

Runoff in Chile: For Defeating Kast and the Right, without Confidence in Boric or His Project

Gabriel Boric’s wide margin of victory over José Antonio Kast in today’s Chilean presidential vote was a surprise. It was a rejection of the strengthening of the Right wing in the first round of the elections. Now that fight against the Right must move to the streets, where the demands from the October 2019 rebellion must be raised again.

La Izquierda Diario Chile

December 20, 2021

MOST RECENT

“I Am A Man”: MLK and the Memphis Sanitation Strike

Martin Luther King Jr was assassinated in Memphis, TN. He was there supporting striking sanitation workers.

Madeleine Freeman

January 17, 2022
Students hold sign that reads "Safe schools should not be a debate."

“I Want to Thank the Staff That Held the Line”: Interview with a Chicago Teacher

Earlier this month, teachers in Chicago voted to resume remote learning rather than return to unsafe working conditions. In response, Chicago Mayor, Lori Lightfoot locked the teachers out of their classes and threatened to stop paying them. After a few days, the Chicago Teachers Union’s House of Delegates voted to suspend the teachers’ action and called them to in person classes. We spoke to a Chicago teacher about this struggle and what it means for educators across the country.

Left Voice

January 17, 2022

Eleanor Marx: A Punk in the 19th Century

Eleanor Marx, the youngest daughter of Karl Marx and herself a socialist activist, was born on this day in 1855. A citizen of the world, she resonated with Shelley and Ibsen and participated in the main theoretical and political debates of her time.

Celeste Murillo

January 16, 2022
Protesters carry a banner that says "Johnson Must Go, He Partied While People Died."

Why “Partygate” Threatens to Bring Down UK Prime Minister

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson is in the midst of a growing political crisis after it became clear that he and his aides violated Covid-19 regulations by having parties. These parties are a slap in the face to the working people of Britain, who were banned from seeing their families while the Prime Minister drank with his cronies.

Ezra Brain

January 16, 2022