Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Unrequited Love: NY Unions Mourn Amazon HQ2

Unions should stop their policy of ‘engagement and cooperation’ with the bosses and represent the interest of working-class communities.

Ioan Georg

March 4, 2019
Facebook Twitter Share
Protesters opposing Amazon's plan to build a headquarters in New York hold a protest outside of an Amazon book store on in Manhattan on Nov. 26, 2018.Stephanie Keith / Getty

By now many of us on the left, and especially those of us in New York City, know all about the Amazon scandal. How the company nearly stole billions of dollars in subsidies for a headquarters that would have most assuredly enriched developers and ran working class families out of Long Island City. We know it was a major victory won this February when Amazon abandoned their plans. But what has not been discussed enough is the role of the union bureaucracies in this whole experience. That is, in the kerfuffle between the RWDSU and the traitorous SEIU 32BJ, and their respective relationships to the deal, some lessons can be gleaned.

It was no secret of course that unions were divided on the question of Amazon. On one side was the RWDSU and the Teamsters who argued against the sweetheart deal, and on the other was SEIU 32BJ and the building trades, who prostrated themselves for the deal.

From 32BJ you have international president Hector Figueroa pleading the importance of keeping Amazon happy. He parroted the bosses’ myth that Amazon would bring in 25,000 jobs and billions of dollars in revenue into the City. Throughout the campaign, which included rallies on both sides of the question, he explained that he had a fundamental disagreement of strategy” with the other unions over the demand of the company’s neutrality in union drives. He maintained that merely by Amazon locating itself in New York City, a progressive community, a union town” that it was “eventually going to lead to some potential change down the road” just as long as the headquarters was built. Certainly, the 11,000 union jobs — some permanent, most not — he believed would have went to the building trades and 32BJ was also a factor outside of strategic considerations. After all, the union did not need to fight for neutrality because Amazon had promised to uphold an agreement “to use unionized security and building workers on its site.” So when Amazon pulled the plug on the deal, Figueroa and 32BJ put out a press release claiming that there was a “missed opportunity to engage one of the largest companies in the world and to create a pathway to union representation for one of the largest groups of predominantly non-union workers in our country.” His unionism is one of ‘engaging’ the boss, and after the Volkswagen debacle in Tennessee, we know the dead-end of cooperating with the boss.

This is business unionism, plain and simple. President Figueroa was willing to sacrifice the rest of the labor movement, not to mention the working class of Long Island City that would have  suffered Amazon’s presence and who made their disapproval to the plan well known. This is the myopic approach of the current union leaderships to serve only their shrinking memberships. Against this method, there are the examples of the teachers strikes that demonstrate the ways in which unions can take the proper lead in fighting for the whole working class and winning over the support necessary to win.

On the other side, you have Stuart Appelbaum, president of RWDSU, who fought for a neutrality agreement from Amazon in order to unionize the hypothetical headquarters. This potential organizing would have occurred alongside the campaigns at the Amazon warehouse on Staten Island that began in December and the union drives at Amazon-owned Whole Foods. His position was summed up by “If you’re aggressively anti-union, we shouldn’t be giving you subsidies.” A Vice-President of the Teamsters, George Miranda, also attacked Amazon for its “atrocious labor history.” Still, if the labor leaders stop only at fighting for union jobs, they lose out on the opportunity to be a tribune for all workers, particularly those who would have been displaced out of their homes. The labor movement will not grow by linear progression, but must jump in leaps and bounds by struggle for the millions of not-yet-organized workers as well as the millions of unionized workers.

It should be remembered too that Governor Cuomo, the x factor in all of this and the main proponent of giving Amazon a whole lot of money, was nominated at the state Democratic Party Convention for his position by none other than Stuart Appelbaum himself. What message does it send when the political face of the union bureaucracies are the Democrats like Cuomo? Or his state budget director that claimed that New York could not afford to allow only unionized companies to enter” and so nonunion companies like Amazon must be enticed with big tax breaks. The money is there for corporate subsidies to corporations that pay so little in taxes already, but not for, say, unionized public works that would actually create those 25,000 jobs for workers who actually live in the neighborhoods?

In the end, Figueroa threw 32BJ’s lot in with Amazon against the working class, while Appelbaum was hamstrung by his support for Democrats. The only way unions will be able to fight back and recover from the bosses’ offensive is through democratic, militant unionism built on fighting the bosses, not through engagement and cooperation.

Facebook Twitter Share

Ioan Georg

Ioan is a factory worker at an optical lens plant in Queens, NY and a shop steward in IUE-CWA Local 463.

Labor Movement

Cargo ship crashing into a bridge in Baltimore on March 26, 2024.

Baltimore Bridge Collapse Reveals Unsafe Working Conditions for Immigrant Workers

Six Latine immigrant workers died in the March 26 bridge collapse in Baltimore. The accident exposed how capitalism perpetuates dangerous working conditions for many immigrants, and funds genocide over crumbling public infrastructure.

Julia Wallace

April 4, 2024

Self Organization and the Mexican Student Strike 

Left Voice member speaks about the massive 1999 Mexican student strike and the role of assemblies.

Jimena Vergara

March 30, 2024

“Our Big Push Was for Union Democracy and a Plan to Win”: An Interview with the Amazon Labour Union Democratic Reform Caucus

Two years after the historic victory at JFK8, Amazon workers voted in a referendum in their union. They want to hold new elections and revise the constitution, as part of a struggle to make ALU more democratic and militant. Left Voice spoke with two organizers to discuss the struggle in ALU.

Luigi Morris

March 20, 2024
A banner reads "Real Wages Or We Strike" at a rally for CUNY, which is experiencing cuts from Mayor Eric Adams and Governor Kathy Hochul.

CUNY Faculty and Staff Have Gone One Year Without a Contract — It’s Time to Strike

CUNY workers have been without a new contract for a full year and the university has yet to make any economic offers. It's time to take action.

Olivia Wood

February 29, 2024

MOST RECENT

U.S. Imperialism is Pushing Tensions in the Middle East to a Boiling Point

U.S. Imperialism's support for Israel is driving the tensions behind Iran's attack and the escalations in the Middle East. It is all the more urgent for the working class to unite with the movement for Palestine against imperialism and chart a way out of the crisis in the region.

Samuel Karlin

April 15, 2024

Thousands of Police Deployed to Shut Down Congress on Palestine in Berlin

This weekend, a Palestine Congress was supposed to take place in the German capital. But 2,500 police were mobilized and shut down the event before the first speech could be held. Multiple Jewish comrades were arrested.

Nathaniel Flakin

April 12, 2024

Liberal Towns in New Jersey Are Increasing Attacks on Pro-Palestine Activists

A group of neighbors in South Orange and Maplewood have become a reference point for pro-Palestine organizing in New Jersey suburbs. Now these liberal towns are upping repression against the local activists.

Samuel Karlin

April 12, 2024

“We Shouldn’t Let this Stop Us”: Suspended Columbia Student Activist Speaks Out

Aidan Parisi, a student at Columbia University’s School of Social Work, was recently suspended and has been threatened with eviction from their graduate student housing for pro-Palestinian activism on campus. Aidan talked to Left Voice about the state of repression, the movement at Columbia, and the path forward for uniting the student movement with the labor movement and other movements against oppression.

Left Voice

April 11, 2024