Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Judge Upholds Firing of UPS Activist for Union Rally In Major Attack on Workers’ Rights and Free Speech

Late last month, in a major blow to workers’ rights and free speech, a judge at an arbitration panel upheld the discharge of UPS driver Ben Douglass. His crime? Speaking out against management retaliation at a rally outside his facility.

Left Voice

November 14, 2022
Facebook Twitter Share
Image: Patrick Semansky/AP Photo

Last month, at an arbitration panel hearing, a judge upheld the discharge of UPS driver and Teamster Ben Douglass for a single comment he made at a September 1 union rally against management retaliation. Douglass, who is an alternate shop steward and outspoken union militant, was accused of “harassment” and  “insubordination” for calling management “liars” and identifying one supervisor as “porn stache.” The comments were made after four supervisors and one security supervisor came outside to surveil and intimidate rally participants. 

Earlier in the summer, UPS management tried to fire Douglass on bogus charges related to not working quickly enough during the heatwave, when temperatures often went above 90 degrees.  And he wasn’t the only one. The same day that Douglass was taken off the job without just cause, UPS also fired Rob Becker, another alternate shop steward, at a facility in Long Island, for getting an iced tea while on the clock. Five months earlier in Massachusetts, they had done the same with Dan Arlin.

Douglass, a UPS driver for almost two years, had been fighting against unsafe work conditions. During this time, he not only rallied his coworkers and fought for better Covid protections, but also spoke out against the terrible conditions both drivers and warehouse workers faced during the heat waves, all while management sat in comfortable air-conditioned offices. While UPS was forced to withdraw some of the most egregious charges against Douglass and reinstated him with full back-pay, the company had since piled on with even more discipline, using any available pretext to try to fire this outspoken critic of the bosses.

At the arbitration panel — the final step of the grievance process — UPS worked hard to paint a picture of Douglass as an incompetent and insubordinate worker, using past instances of disciplinary action they meted out as part of a longer campaign of targeting. They went hard at Douglass for his speech at the rally against retaliation, with supervisors saying how they felt “humiliated”. These are the same supervisors that shout at, bully and harass workers every day with impunity. Indeed, supervisors who use racist, sexist and other bigoted language are more likely to get promoted than to be disciplined themselves.

The judicial order that upheld Douglass’s discharge serves to legitimize UPS’s union busting efforts. But this ruling also sets a dangerous precedent for the labor movement as a whole, undermining the basic rights of concerted union activity and free speech. What is to stop UPS, Amazon, Starbucks and other companies from retaliating against workers speaking out at rallies, actions or picket lines moving forward? Such rulings illustrate the harsh reality that labor law, the arbitration process, the judges, and the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) — all the official structures for responding to class-conflict — are ultimately tipped heavily in favor of the bosses. Our current legal system, built to uphold the interests of the rich and powerful, allows management to commit wage theft, retaliate against union militants and neglect health and safety, all without major repercussions. Meanwhile, unjustly fired workers like Douglass face an uphill legal battle that can take many months, if not years, to resolve, and there is no guarantee of victory. 

Prior to his discharge being upheld, Douglass filed charges with the NLRB against UPS for retaliatory discipline. Hopefully, the NLRB will overturn the outrageous ruling by the panel judge and order Douglass to be reinstated with full back pay and seniority. However, even if the fight for Douglass’s reinstatement is ultimately successful — which is an open question — it is likely that the process will become a drawn-out legal contest. Both Teamsters Local 804, which is pursuing the case, and UPS, have the potential to appeal whatever ruling is made by the NLRB. It is conceivable that this case could ultimately end up being decided by the Supreme Court. 

UPS’s firing of Ben Douglass is an attack on the whole labor movement, one that needs to be fought tooth and nail. We condemn this outrageous assault on free speech. With the judge’s ruling, we see once again a state apparatus that intervenes on behalf of the bosses, not workers. We must draw lessons from this injustice: working class power comes from shop-floor organization, solidarity, and willingness to take militant action. Strong rank-and-file organization is the best safeguard against victimization.  

Facebook Twitter Share

Left Voice

Militant journalism, revolutionary politics.

Labor Movement

“Grueling Working Conditions and Low Wages”: A Testimonial from a UPS Warehouse Worker

Workers in UPS warehouses are among the most precarious workers in the logistics industry. As the 2023 Teamsters contract negotiations approaches, a UPS warehouse worker speaks out about his working conditions and calls for unity in struggle among UPS drivers and warehouse workers.

Nehuen Latif

November 30, 2022
Twitter’s headquarters in San Francisco. Logo on a grey building.

Workers Built Twitter — They Should Own It, Not Elon Musk

Corporations like Twitter cannot function without the workers who do the daily labor.

Kyle Thibodeau

November 27, 2022

Education Workers Have the Power to Win in Toronto

A rank-and-file educational worker who participated in the historic strike earlier this month in Toronto discusses how fellow workers can fight back against the Doug Ford administration and win their demands.

Martin Reilly

November 20, 2022

48,000 University of California Academic Workers Begin Historic Strike

On November 14, 48,000 academic workers across the University of California system began the largest higher education strike in history. Their fight could inspire higher education workers across the country.

Brian H. Silverstein

November 15, 2022


South African president Cyril Ramaphosa in a suit

“Farmgate” Threatens the Very Foundations of Capitalist Stability in South Africa

South African President Cyril Ramaphosa faces an impeachment vote Tuesday. More than a simple case of corruption, it’s a political crisis of the ruling party and of capitalist stability in the country.

Sam Carliner

December 5, 2022

Understanding the Carnage at Colorado Springs

The heinous violence displayed in Colorado Springs is a stark reminder of the menacing, lethal threat that today’s determined far right continues to pose to trans and queer people, and anyone living outside capitalism’s imposed sexual and gender boundaries.

Keegan O'Brien

December 4, 2022
Mapuche people standing with a flag

The Case of the Mapuche: What Can Trotsky Teach Us about the Fight against National Oppression?

Trotsky’s reflections on the social aspect of permanent revolution have deep implications for building working-class hegemony through solidarity with oppressed peoples.

Juan Valenzuela

December 4, 2022

“We Sold Out the People Who Elected Us”: UC Bargaining Team Member Speaks Out About Union Concessions

Here we publish the testimony of a graduate student worker on strike at the University of California, who is part of the bargaining team for UAW Local 2865. Wednesday night, the bargaining team voted 10-9 to make severe concessions to the university.