Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Why Hamilton Is the Most Right-Wing Musical on Broadway

In the midst of a movement against systemic racism, Disney has released a filmed version of the musical Hamilton. But when one looks past its diverse cast and enjoyable score, it becomes clear that Hamilton glamorizes slave owners.

Sybil Davis

July 7, 2020
Facebook Twitter Share
CHICAGO COMPANY Hamilton Company. Photo Credit: Joan Marcus

The day before July 4, Disney+ released a filmed version of the hit Broadway musical Hamilton. Unsurprisingly, the musical once again became a social media phenomenon. The current uprisings against police violence, however, have created something of a backlash against the musical. Hamilton is now being interrogated at a much deeper political level than it was when it first premiered in 2015.

While Hamilton did give opportunities to Black and Brown performers, who are often severely limited in their options, it is important to also engage with Hamilton as a piece of political art. Writer, composer, and star Lin-Manuel Miranda has been very explicit about his attempts to connect the story of Alexander Hamilton with more contemporary themes. Even a cursory investigation of the text of the musical reveals it to be one of the most conservative shows in recent memory. Miranda has written a very effective piece of propaganda for the slave owners who founded this country. He adds insult to injury by having Black and Latinx actors portray the very people who oppressed and murdered their ancestors.

An Immigrant’s Story

The central conceit of Hamilton is that Alexander Hamilton was a “young, scrappy, and hungry” immigrant whose journey to make it in America is comparable to that of a hip-hop star rising from a poor background to fame and fortune. This journey, Miranda claims, is an allegory for the American experience writ large. This concept is where the politics of Hamilton start to go wrong. 

To begin with, Miranda equates immigrants — specifically Latinx immigrants — with colonizers. This is key to how Miranda views the Founding Fathers. We are meant to see working-class people from Latin America coming to the U.S. in search of jobs in the same light as wealthy Europeans coming to the colonies to, well, colonize them. For example, the musical’s much quoted line “Immigrants, we get the job done” is said by the Marquis de Lafayette, a French aristocrat. Is this really a good example of an “immigrant” in the United States?

Throughout Hamilton, a class perspective is not only missing but is actively obscured. Miranda presents his characters as substitutes for young people today who want to make something of themselves. If Hamilton was able to work his way up the ladder of American society, then so can any immigrant who tries hard enough. Miranda seems to fully believe this kind of Horatio Alger story. But this capitalist myth-making has been challenged in the American theatre dating back to Death of a Salesman, making Miranda’s propaganda seem horribly dated. Hamilton offers up a conservative perspective on America that is far to the right of most modern theatre. 

One of the songs in Hamilton states “you have no control, who lives, who dies, who tells your story.” So why exactly did Miranda choose to tell this story? He claims that he picked up a biography and fell in love with Hamilton. But to accept this story as presented, one has to drink the Kool-Aid of American exceptionalism. At every turn, Miranda chooses to present the traditional narrative of the American Revolution which erases the actual struggles of people of color during this period. To name one example, the Haitian Revolution occurred in the time covered by the musical, ending mere months before Hamilton died. The Hatian Revolution is documented in its own page-turning historical book — Black Jacobins by CLR James — and could just as easily be turned into a musical. But Miranda isn’t interested in actually telling the stories of people of color rising up against their oppressors. Instead, Miranda chooses to use diverse casting to tell a story about the Founding Fathers.

Slave Owners

By removing class, Miranda allows himself to rehabilitate a collection of slave owners with catchy pop tunes. Now, Alexander Hamilton, George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and their compatriots are no longer bourgeois slave owners, but rather plucky freedom fighters and young men trying to make something of themselves. This bourgeois conception of the American Revolution as a war of freedom erases the fact that the freedoms won for the wealthy white colonists were built off of the labor and murder of Black and Native people.

Throughout the play, characters talk of “rising up” against oppressors. Of course, this takes on extra meaning given the largely Black and Latinx cast. Our heroes are presented as members of an oppressed group who are revolting against tyranny. But they were fighting for a bourgeois version of liberty. Indeed, even Hamilton himself bought and sold slaves on behalf of his in-laws and managed an import business that engaged in the slave trade. All the facts about slavery and genocide are swept under the rug.

The American Revolution put a bourgeoisie in power, and their ideals of freedom did not apply to everyone. Black people remained enslaved, women were still deprived of most legal rights, and the genocide against the Native peoples only escalated. The American Revolution is a textbook example of a bourgeois revolution, which proclaims the goal of democracy and universal rights, but creates a system based on capitalist exploitation.

Miranda offers no critical perspective of any kind.  The show presents Hamilton’s brand of American capitalism as being “a work of genius.” The acknowledgement that the South has it “made in the shade” because they “don’t pay for labor” is a shamefully glib acknowledgement of the new country’s slave-based economy. In every scene, Miranda shows his capitalist colors. 

Is there anything less progressive than presenting the Founding Fathers as moral stalwarts fighting for liberation? Miranda views the Founding Fathers as great heroes and slavery as just an unfortunate lapse in judgement. The political point-of-view in Hamilton is actually to the right of most modern K-12 history books. In a time when protesters for racial justice are tearing down statues of slave owners, this is a musical designed to celebrate those same slave owners.

In his review of Hamilton, Ishmael Reed summed up the cognitive dissonance present in having people of color play slave owners: “Now I have seen everything. Can you imagine Jewish actors in Berlin’s theaters taking roles of Goering? Goebbels? Eichmann? Hitler?” As memorials to genocidal slave owners fall in cities across the country, we must understand that one created in 2015 sits on Disney+. This isn’t to say, of course, that we must pull Hamilton down and hide it away from public consumption. But we must have difficult discussions about what, exactly, the show is saying. 

Facebook Twitter Share

Sybil Davis

Sybil is a trans activist, artist, and education worker in New York City.

Arts

Exploitation in Storytelling: The Conditions of Manga Artists in Japan

Anime and Manga are popular forms of storytelling from Japan that are becoming more and more popular in the West. Here we observe the labor conditions of Manga authors themselves as well as the general labor conditions in Japan.

Carmin Maffea

August 14, 2023

Turning the Greatest Anti-war Novel Ever into Bourgeois Propaganda

All Quiet on the Western Front won four Oscars, and it’s not hard to see why. The production — depicting the horrors of World War I — is spectacular. Yet the producers did not at all understand Erich Maria Remarque’s novel. Spoilers follow.

Nathaniel Flakin

March 16, 2023

Five Years after Ursula K. Le Guin’s Death, We Need Her More Than Ever

Ursula K. Le Guin tended the embers of revolt in a new age of imperialism and counterrevolution. She tasked us with stoking them into a blaze.

Jason Koslowski

January 22, 2023
The cast of "Glass Onion" lounge next to a pool.

Glass Onion: Liberalism’s Dream

Netflix’s new movie, Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery, is the ruling class’s dream about itself.

Jason Koslowski

January 4, 2023

MOST RECENT

Black UAW workers, a black-and-white image, holding signs that say "UAW ON STRIKE."

To Achieve Black Liberation, Class Independence Is Key

A united, working-class party fighting oppression is our only hope for Black liberation.

Tristan Taylor

February 29, 2024
A banner reads "Real Wages Or We Strike" at a rally for CUNY, which is experiencing cuts from Mayor Eric Adams and Governor Kathy Hochul.

CUNY Faculty and Staff Have Gone One Year Without a Contract — It’s Time to Strike

CUNY workers have been without a new contract for a full year and the university has yet to make any economic offers. It's time to take action.

Olivia Wood

February 29, 2024
Aaron Bushnell, who self-immolated in protest of the genocide in Palestine.

Aaron Bushnell’s Cry of Despair in the Face of Genocide

The media and international community was profoundly affected by the self-immolation of U.S. soldier Aaron Bushnell in protest against the genocide in Gaza. His death and desperate act of protest starkly shows the cruelty and brutality of U.S. Imperialism and Zionism.

Enzo Tresso

February 28, 2024
Florida governor Ron DeSantis stands at a podium that reds "Higher Education Reform"

U.S. Higher Education Is Being Gutted, but We Can Fight Back

Across the United States, higher education is being gutted through program eliminations and budget cuts. We must prepare to fight these attacks with everything we have.

Olivia Wood

February 28, 2024