Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

#AllThatsLeftPod: Stalinism, Anti-Communism, and the Fate of the Soviet Union — An Interview with Doug Greene

In this episode, we interview author and historian Douglas Greene about his new book “Stalinism and the Dialectics of Saturn: Anticommunism, Marxism, and the Fate of the Soviet Union.”

Left Voice

August 14, 2023
Facebook Twitter Share
All That's Left, the podcast from Left Voice.

Listen on Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Online

*

Does socialism inevitably lead to Stalinism? Are socialist revolutions doomed to fail? As Douglas Greene points out in his new book Stalinism and the Dialectics of Saturn: Anticommunism, Marxism, and the Fate of the Soviet Union, answering these questions “is not an antiquarian concern or mere academic exercise, but it will determine whether human emancipation remains possible.”

The idea that Stalinism was the dark, unavoidable fate of the Russian Revolution casts a shadow over socialism and its history. Anti-communists embrace this view because they see Stalinism as an evil and totalitarian force, springing seemingly out of nowhere. From the Right, anti-communists like Winston Churchill and Alexander Solzhenitsyn — and Adolf Hitler on the very Far Right — saw communism as a dangerous virus, and tied it to subversive Jews.

However, anti-communism doesn’t just come from the Right. Some on the Left, too, cast Stalinism as the inevitable result of communist revolution. Writer George Orwell, for example, viewed Stalinism and communism as totalitarian and stemming from an evil lust for power. Like their anticommunist counterparts on the Right, these more progressive sectors viewed Stalinism as pure evil, coming out of the blue, without an attempt to understand the material forces that led to Stalin’s rise.

On the other hand, supporters of Stalin and the Soviet Union, particularly from the world’s Communist parties, argued that Stalinism was a historical necessity and the only way for the working class to reach the glorious end goal of communism. According to this reasoning, whatever compromises the Soviet Union made, they were a necessary price to pay as part of the iron laws of history. Whoever opposed Stalinism was opposed to the working class — and to history itself.

Whether Stalinism is portrayed as a savior or as the antichrist, both anticommunists and Stalin’s supporters fundamentally agree that there was no alternative to Stalinism. And if there’s no alternative, then every attempt at liberation will inevitably lead to a repressive dictatorship and terror, and that would mean there’s no emancipatory potential in socialist revolution.

You might be interested in: Michael Harrington and the Origins of DSA: An Interview with Doug Greene

But as Greene argues, the Russian Revolution was not doomed to fail, and socialism does not necessarily lead to Stalinism. Both the anti-communist and the pro-Stalinist perspectives take an ahistorical approach without a material analysis of Stalin’s counterrevolution.  

Stalinism was a result of concrete material conditions in the Soviet Union. Although the Bolsheviks won the civil war in 1921, the war had decimated the working class and the workers’ councils (soviets), and left the economy in ruins. Additionally, the Soviet Union was very isolated since revolutions had been defeated elsewhere. It was in the context of this political void — as well as economic devastation and scarcity — that the Soviet bureaucracy, centered around Stalin, managed to solidify its rule. 

This historical materialist approach, which was adopted by Leon Trotsky, doesn’t view Stalinism in a framework of good or evil, or damnation or salvation. Rather, it shows us that Stalinism wasn’t pre-ordained or written in the stars, nor was it the fulfillment of Bolshevism. Material circumstances and processes of class struggle gave rise to Stalinism and its terrors, as well as to the betrayal of workers and international revolution. 

On this episode, we interview Greene, an independent Marxist historian, about his new book. He explains what characterized Stalinism, as well as the approaches to Stalinism which incorrectly frame it as an inevitability. He contrasts this with the historical materialist perspective, drawing on Trotsky’s analyses.

Finally, we discuss why this debate is so important today. As Greene writes, “The Stalinist outcome in Russia was not a fated outcome as if preordained by some god of history. Stalinism can only be claimed as inevitable by ignoring the communist roads not taken.” Understanding Stalinism isn’t just about understanding the past — it’s about envisioning the future.

Greene is also the author of A Failure of Vision: Michael Harrington and the Limits of Democratic Socialism and Communist Insurgent: Blanqui’s Politics of Revolution and he has a forthcoming book on Karl Kautsky and neo-Kautskyism entitled The Renegade’s Revenge.

Stalinism and the Dialectics of Saturn: Anticommunism, Marxism, and the Fate of the Soviet Unionis available here.

You can read more of Doug’s work here and follow him on Twitter

Listen to the episode on Spotify on Apple Podcasts.

Support this podcast on Patreon.

Facebook Twitter Share

Left Voice

Militant journalism, revolutionary politics.

Ideas & Debates

The Movement for Palestine Needs Independent, Working-Class Politics

As the brutal genocide of Palestinians continues with the help of the Biden administration, there is maneuver underway to co-opt the movement for Palestine. We need to have a democratic and independent movement that relies on the power of the working class, the student movement, and mobilizations in the streets.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

April 7, 2024

Self Organization and the Mexican Student Strike 

Left Voice member speaks about the massive 1999 Mexican student strike and the role of assemblies.

Jimena Vergara

March 30, 2024

The Convulsive Interregnum of the International Situation

The capitalist world is in a "permacrisis" — a prolonged period of instability which may lead to catastrophic events. The ongoing struggles for hegemony could lead to open military conflicts.

Claudia Cinatti

March 22, 2024

“Poor Things” Floats Like a Butterfly and Stings Like a Butterfly

Poor Things is a fantastical comedy with beautiful set design and costumes and an Oscar-winning performance from Emma Stone. So why did it leave me feeling so empty? Despite juggling feminist and socialist ideas, the film is ideologically muddled and often self-contradictory.

Basil Rozlaban

March 16, 2024

MOST RECENT

Thousands of Police Deployed to Shut Down Congress on Palestine in Berlin

This weekend, a Palestine Congress was supposed to take place in the German capital. But 2,500 police were mobilized and shut down the event before the first speech could be held. Multiple Jewish comrades were arrested.

Nathaniel Flakin

April 12, 2024

Liberal Towns in New Jersey Are Increasing Attacks on Pro-Palestine Activists

A group of neighbors in South Orange and Maplewood have become a reference point for pro-Palestine organizing in New Jersey suburbs. Now these liberal towns are upping repression against the local activists.

Samuel Karlin

April 12, 2024

“We Shouldn’t Let this Stop Us”: Suspended Columbia Student Activist Speaks Out

Aidan Parisi, a student at Columbia University’s School of Social Work, was recently suspended and has been threatened with eviction from their graduate student housing for pro-Palestinian activism on campus. Aidan talked to Left Voice about the state of repression, the movement at Columbia, and the path forward for uniting the student movement with the labor movement and other movements against oppression.

Left Voice

April 11, 2024

Fired by a German University for Solidarity with Palestine — Interview with Nancy Fraser

The University of Cologne canceled a guest professorship with the philosophy professor from The New School. In this interview, she speaks about Germany dividing between "Good Jews" and "Bad Jews," her politicization in the civil rights movement, and her time in an Israeli kibbutz.

Nathaniel Flakin

April 10, 2024