Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Capitalist Governments Say: Shelter in Place — and Go to Work!

In many European countries, the police can fine or arrest you for meeting with friends in a park. But we are still expected to spend eight hours in an office with tens or hundreds of other people. Governments in Germany, France, Italy, Australia, and to some degree, the U.S. are all practicing this seemingly contradictory policy. They are defending capitalist profits, not people’s lives.

Nathaniel Flakin

March 25, 2020
Facebook Twitter Share

Since Sunday, Germany has been on lockdown. The federal and state governments prohibited gatherings of more than two people. In Berlin, where I am writing this, people are required to carry government-issued identification including their address at all times.

We are still allowed to go to the supermarket or the pharmacy, or take a walk, but other than that we are supposed to stay at home. All schools have been closed since March 17. Bars were all shut down three days before that. These are drastic but important measures to slow the spread of the coronavirus.  Social distancing is necessary to stop the spread. 

There is one huge exception, however: People are still allowed and expected to go to work. While many people are working from home, countless others are still commuting to an office or a factory, which is why buses and subways are still running. This includes essential workers, such as healthcare or supermarket workers, but it also includes thousands who are being forced to come into the office and do not know why.

This policy appears completely irrational. The police can fine or even arrest three people sitting together in a park because they could spread the virus. So how can it be acceptable for tens or hundreds of people to sit together in an enclosed space for eight hours working for corporate profits, not to fight the pandemic? Are the German authorities working on the assumption that the virus will only infect people in their free time? But Germany’s absurd policy is no exception. Many countries are responding to the crisis with similarly contradictory and ineffective decrees.

Contradictory and Ineffective

France has similar policies, but is enforcing them with the iron fist of a police state. People can only leave their home for only one hour per day, staying within one kilometer of their address. They need to print out a certificate describing what they are doing. Police are everywhere, and they might even check a person’s groceries to see if they consider the shopping “essential.” Police fined over 4,000 people on the first day of the lockdown —  135 euros a pop. President Emmanuel Macron built up this repressive apparatus to fight the Yellow Vests rebellion. Despite these harsh rules, however, French workers are still being sent to work. Airbus, for example, keeps producing airplanes — taking masks for the factory floor that are desperately needed in hospitals.

Italy went on lockdown on March 9. But it wasn’t until March 21 that the government of Prime Minister Giuseppe Comte declared the closure of all nonessential businesses. So for two weeks, the entire country was told to stay at home and practice social distancing — and simultaneously to go to work! But even the decree that now supposedly stops production is a joke. The government, responding to the pressure of the capitalists’ association Confindustria, has declared whole sectors of industry “essential” even though they are not producing materials to help with the crisis, including plastic, coal, chemistry, and rubber. Even call centers, where workers are pressed together in cubicles for hours on end, have been deemed “strategic.” In Italy, there have already been strikes to shut down auto factories and other sectors that no reasonable people would consider “essential” in a pandemic. Today there is a general strike in Italy to shut down all production.

In Australia, the government of Scott Morrison is telling people to stay home unless it’s “absolutely necessary.” But this same government is refusing to close schools nationally, as it is apparently “absolutely necessary” to keep kids in school so their parents can go to work. Many offices and factories remain open.

The United States has no consistent policy, but states like New York and California have gone on lockdown. In the states, the lockdown is much more lax than in Europe and non-essential work continues.  Companies have been trying to declare themselves “essential” and force their employees to come into work despite the health risks. Even Starbucks, a company worth $66 billion, wanted employees to keep making “essential” coffee, while Tesla refused to shut down its “essential” car plant for almost a week. Despite projections that the worst of the pandemic will last well into April, Donald Trump’s plan is to open up all non-essential businesses by Easter.  

Workers’ Control

These policies might sound wildly irrational: capitalist governments want people to socially distance in their free time — but to work together in close quarters on the job. But this corresponds to the logic of capitalism. Governments are ultimately not interested in protecting public health. Their job is to protect the profits of a tiny minority who own the means of production.

So the question is: who can, and who should, decide what is “essential” or not? 

The answer is simple. Workers themselves know whether the risks are necessary for society. Tellingly, most healthcare workers are not only continuing to work, but doing long shifts in dangerous conditions. Workers producing protective gear and disinfectant around the world are also working overtime. 

It is the workers at a Starbucks or an office or a factory who can decide if it is necessary for them to risk spreading the infection in order to save lives. That is why we don’t need capitalist governments making decisions about what production is “essential.” We need workers’ control of production so working people can make these decisions collectively.

Workers at the big U.S. auto plants decided that manufacturing cars was not essential, and shut down their industry with wildcat strikes. But if these same factories started producing ventilators or other necessary equipment, we can be certain that these same workers would show up and equip themselves with the necessary protective gear.

Facebook Twitter Share

Nathaniel Flakin

Nathaniel is a freelance journalist and historian from Berlin. He is on the editorial board of Left Voice and our German sister site Klasse Gegen Klasse. Nathaniel, also known by the nickname Wladek, has written a biography of Martin Monath, a Trotskyist resistance fighter in France during World War II, which has appeared in German, in English, and in French. He is on the autism spectrum.

Instagram

Ideas & Debates

China’s Rise, ‘Diminished Dependency,’ and Imperialism in Times of World Disorder

In this broad-ranging interview, originally published in LINKS, Trotskyist Fraction member Esteban Mercatante discusses how recent global shifts in processes of capital accumulation have contributed to China’s rise, the new (and old) mechanisms big powers use to plunder the Global South, and its implications for anti-imperialist and working-class struggles today.

Esteban Mercatante

September 22, 2023

What Is the Role of a “Green Card Soldier”? Interview with Sofya Aptekar

While both capitalist parties fight over diversity in the military, Sofya Aptekar’s new book, Green Card Soldier, looks at the experiences of immigrant soldiers in the U.S. military and how oppressed communities are used by the military to legitimize and expand empire.

Sam Carliner

August 22, 2023
All That's Left, the podcast from Left Voice.

#AllThatsLeftPod: Stalinism, Anti-Communism, and the Fate of the Soviet Union — An Interview with Doug Greene

In this episode, we interview author and historian Douglas Greene about his new book “Stalinism and the Dialectics of Saturn: Anticommunism, Marxism, and the Fate of the Soviet Union.”

Left Voice

August 14, 2023

How the Daughters of a Nazi General Became Communist Spies

As Hitler rose to power, two daughters of Germany’s top general became spies for the Communist Party. A new biography tells the story of how hatred for fascism and its aristocratic collaborators led them to become class traitors.

Nathaniel Flakin

August 12, 2023

MOST RECENT

President Biden giving a speech on Friday, September 15, about the UAW strike. A UAW sign in the background.

Joe Biden Is Afraid of the UAW Strike. That’s a Good Thing.

A few days ago, Biden called on the bosses of the Big Three automakers to give concessions to the striking UAW workers. It’s because he’s scared of the UAW’s power.

Enid Brain

September 20, 2023
Migrants from Northern Africa sit in lines on the Italian island of Lampedusa.

Crisis in Lampedusa: Down with Fortress Europe, Open the Borders!

The way out of the immigration crisis is through the struggle against imperialism. This is a declaration from the European organizations of the Trotskyist Fraction - Fourth International.

NYC Mayor Eric Adams stands at a podium.

The Housing Crisis and Migrant Crisis Are Crises of Capitalism

As thousands of people come to the U.S. seeking shelter, politicians around the country are claiming that housing in the U.S. is already in crisis and that there is no room for them. Both the “migrant crisis” and “housing crisis” are crises created and exacerbated by capitalism.

Mike Pappas

September 20, 2023

To Win, the UAW Strike Must Be Organized from Below

The strike at the Big Three has put the working class at the center of national politics. The autoworkers’ demands are bold and touch on issues of growing exploitation across the country. To win big, the strike must be organized from below.

Tristan Taylor

September 18, 2023