Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

There’s No Hope for the Democratic Party. But We Can Still Win Medicare for All

Bernie Sanders had a terrible night on Super Tuesday. But, the fight for Medicare for All and other progressive reforms aren’t about electing Sanders. They will only be won if the working class and oppressed fight for them without putting faith in a Democratic Party in the service of the capitalists and a “democratic process” rigged in favor of the establishment.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

March 4, 2020
Facebook Twitter Share

There is no sugar coating it. Last night was a terrible night for Bernie Sanders.

He lost Massachusetts, which he was expected to win by 7 points.

He lost Virginia, not by a narrow margin, but by 30 points. 

He lost Texas, even though he was projected to pull off a victory.

It seems that after California, Sanders will be trailing Biden by about 75 delegates. The map of upcoming primaries looks bad. States like Florida, with their 219 pledged delegates are unlikely to support Bernie Sanders. And with Michael Bloomberg dropping out of the race and putting his millions behind Joe Biden, it looks even worse for Bernie Sanders. 

Does this mean that the Democratic Party electorate isn’t as progressive as we thought it was? Does this mean that people just aren’t ready for Medicare for All? 

I’m not sure anyone has the definitive answer to these questions, but my feeling is that the answer to the above question is no. Medicare for All polled with huge support in all outgoing polls, from Alabama (51 percent to 43 percent) to Texas (64 to 33 percent). Well over half of voters supported free college. And “socialism” is no longer a scary word: with a favorable view of socialism polling above an unfavorable view of socialism in Texas, California, North Carolina, and Tennessee. 

And yet, the Democratic Party is on the path to nominating a bumbling conservative as their nominee. As many people have pointed out, Biden can hardly get a coherent sentence out; gaffes abound — just this week he confused his wife with his sister, talked about Super Thursday (instead of Super Tuesday), and botched the Declaration of Independence. Donald Trump is going to eat him alive on the debate stage. Joe Biden is not electable. 

But I actually don’t want to make the electability argument. That’s not what this is about. 

The biggest problem isn’t Biden’s gaffes. It’s his record. It’s his support for segregation, his leadership roles in the war on drugs and the war in Iraq. It’s the fact that he wrote the 1994 Crime Bill that imprisoned millions of Black and brown people and expanded the military industrial complex. It’s his role in the Clarence Thomas Supreme Court hearings, which Biden supervised as the chair of the Senate judiciary committee and during which he oversaw the systematic degradation of Anita Hill. In this sense, both Biden and Trump are united in a racist, sexist, and xenophobic program in the interests of American capitalists. 

So how is this idiot well on his way to being the Democratic Party nominee? 

This happened because, as Ezra Brain explains, “the establishment has decided that enough is enough and has organized to defeat Sanders — and on Super Tuesday, that establishment delivered. The media and the establishment united to successfully bring back the corpse of Joe Biden after his fall in the polls in recent months. The media played up Sanders’ inane Cuba comments and the idea that a “socialist” could never win against Donald Trump. Barack Obama and his surrogates rallied behind Biden and he encouraged Pete Buttigieg to support Biden. As NBC put it, “there appears to be a quiet hand behind the rapid movement: former President Barack Obama.” 

Despite the millions of young people who have been knocking on doors, phone banking and putting their all into Sanders’ campaign, it seems that this will be no match to the power of the Democratic Party establishment and the corporate media. The Democrats are the party of the capitalists and cutting into the profits of insurance companies with Medicare for All is just too “radical” for them. Joe Biden will support the health care status quo which benefits the interests of large insurance companies. Capitalists know this, hence the rise in health insurance stocks after Super Tuesday.

And even if Bernie had a better night and had higher chances of winning a plurality of the delegates coming into the Democratic National Convention, superdelegates were always likely to keep Sanders from the nomination. In fact, the leaders of the party already stated that they were willing to alienate their base in order to stop Sanders. As the New York Times reports, “Interviews with dozens of Democratic Party officials, including 93 superdelegates, found overwhelming opposition to handing Mr. Sanders the nomination if he fell short of a majority of delegates”— even if that alienated much of Sanders’ base and damaged the Democratic Party.”

The scales were always tipped against Bernie Sanders.

But even if Sanders were to win the nomination, confront the corporate interests lining up behind Donald Trump, and win the presidency, then what? With the Democratic and Republican Party in Congress opposing Medicare for All even now, how could he get it through?

I agree in part with what Bernie Sanders has had to say about this in the past: the answer is mobilize. However, though Sanders has conceded that passing M4A will require people in the streets, he hasn’t actually called for such mobilizations. But Congress won’t pass any progressive reform unless there is pressure from the working class — Congress won’t pass any progressive reform unless we fight for it. It certainly won’t take on the billion dollar insurance industry if we don’t mobilize. With the coming coronavirus epidemic likely to hit the United States, the issue of healthcare becomes even more urgent. 

As a DSA member, I’m already getting emails that the response is to buckle down and canvass and phone bank more. Jacobin claims that “Bernie Sanders Can Still Win the Nomination and the Presidency.” Maybe that’s not out of the question. But what happened on Super Tuesday is just a small example of what can happen with the establishment lined up against Sanders. It’s just a taste of what the Democratic Party establishment will do to stop policies like Medicare for All. So let’s stop funneling our time and energy on this failed electoral strategy and this failed attempt to “use” the Democratic Party to build the project we actually want.

Because the issue is, this isn’t about Bernie Sanders. It’s about the folks who die because they don’t have health insurance. It’s about the folks who lose their homes due to medical debt. It’s about the climate crisis created by capitalism. It’s about the millions whose lives have been destroyed as a result of US imperialist policy. 

And for those of us who are socialists, the struggle is about building a world without exploitation, without oppression and imperialism. It’s about the end of private property and having all of society democratically run by the working class and oppressed. We deserve so much more than Medicare for All. We need to fight for socialism — which isn’t the new deal liberalism of Bernie Sanders. That’s why I (and all of the Left Voice editorial board) never supported Sanders: because we want to fight for socialism with an uncompromising anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist position — which Bernie Sanders doesn’t have (in fact, Sanders has supported the US imperialist machine). Our socialism must be rooted in the working class, building up our own, socialist working class party, not the corporate Democratic Party. It’s their party, and I don’t think it makes sense to spend our precious time and energy registering people for that very party. We have to build our own. 

Now that Sanders is struggling in the polls, I think it’s the wrong reaction to just double down on the canvassing and door knocking for Bernie Sanders. Because this is about the fight for healthcare, for education and for the environment, not about Bernie Sanders. And we’ll need to fight in the streets against both the Democrats and Republicans, whether or not Bernie is the nominee in order to get any reform passed. And so, we need to begin that fight now. We need to use the energy of the millions of people who are inspired by Sanders’ policies to mobilize in the streets. We should mobilize for Medicare for All and the fight against climate change. We should call for a massive mobilization, all over the country, for the issues that most voters agree with: universal healthcare and free education. 

Because even Bernie Sanders knows that elections aren’t the way to win reforms. I know that millions of his supporters know that that’s the case as well.  All of those unions who supported Sanders, who held massive rallies with tens of thousands of workers, must do more than endorse Medicare for All. It’s time to mobilize the working class. The DSA, whose members number over 55,000 people must move the fight to the streets.

And we’ll need our own, working class, socialist party to organize that fight and the many fights that are to come. We’ll need our own party that is actually on our side to organize the fight for reforms and the fight for socialism. This isn’t about being anti-electoral: this kind of party could and should run our own candidates. It’s about organizing among working class and oppressed  folks who can actually push the fight for socialism forward, not among our class enemies who are going to pull the rug out from under us at every chance they get.

Facebook Twitter Share

Tatiana Cozzarelli

Tatiana is a former middle school teacher and current Urban Education PhD student at CUNY.

United States

Our Movement Is the Cure: Fighting for Healthcare Means Fighting for Socialism

On July 30 activists marched and rallied in Washington, DC, calling for a more humane healthcare system. Physician and Left Voice member Mike Pappas spoke at the rally about how capitalism and health aren’t compatible. Below is the text from his speech.

Mike Pappas

August 2, 2022

Michigan Court of Appeals Gives County Prosecutors Right to Enforce Abortion Ban

Today a Michigan Court ruled that prosecutors in counties across the state have the authority to enforce a 1931 law that prohibits almost all forms of abortion.

Tristan Taylor

August 1, 2022
On the left a white sign with blue text reads "nurses demand action!" in all caps and on the right a sign reads in blue capitalized text "monkeypox is not just a gay thing"

If We Die of Monkeypox, Leave Our Bodies on the Steps of the WHO

On July 23, 2022, the WHO declared monkeypox a global public health emergency, but access to testing and vaccination is still limited. The struggle to fight the spread of monkeypox is inextricably linked to the fight against homophobia, racism, and imperialism.

K.S. Mehta

July 31, 2022

Police Murder Bronx Teenager for Carrying a Water Gun

An off-duty corrections officer, Don Middleton, shot and killed 18-year-old Raymond Chaluisant, who was playing with a water gun while riding as a passenger in a friend’s car in his Bronx neighborhood.

Emma Lee

July 26, 2022


British Postal Workers Reject Below-Inflation Contract Offer and Announce Upcoming Strike

The union representing postal workers in Britain has announced four days of strikes in the coming weeks — the first such labor action since 2009.

Illustration of a bald eagle on the left and yellow dragon on the right, face-to-face, with the flags of the U.S., R.O.C., and P.R.C. in the background

China and the U.S.: War Games in a Tense World

The visit to Taiwan by Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, has led to a new escalation in tensions between the United States and China. Beijing responded by launching missiles right under Taiwan’s nose — war games on the knife-edge.

Esteban Mercatante

August 10, 2022

With Nationwide Rallies, UPS Teamsters Kick Off Their 2023 Contract Campaign

Last week, UPS Teamsters organized rallies of thousands of workers across the country to kick off their 2023 contract campaign. Left Voice joined in solidarity.

Luigi Morris

August 10, 2022

Cops Out of Martial Arts: You Can’t Make “More Humane” Agents of State Terror

Leandro Lo, a world champion in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, was recently shot and killed by an off-duty cop in Brazil. Martial arts coaches and practitioners often welcome cops into their spaces, saying they’re then less likely to use deadly force. Let’s be clear: cops have no place in martial arts schools

Mike Pappas

August 10, 2022