Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Union Leadership Accepts Paltry Wage Deal Just as South African Metalworkers’ Strike Begins to Hurt the Capitalists

On Thursday, the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (NUMSA) called off a major strike of at least 155,000 workers just as it was starting to gain momentum and was about to strike a major blow against the capitalists’ assault on the workers.

Emma Lee

October 23, 2021
Facebook Twitter Share

On Thursday, the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (NUMSA) called off a major strike of 155,000 workers. Workers are anticipated to return to work Monday after NUMSA accepted a three-year wage offer from the Steel and Engineering Industries Federation of Southern Africa (SEIFSA), an employer association representing bosses in the metals and engineering industries.

Since October 5, metal workers have been on strike demanding higher pay, in an action that has blocked the supply chain of parts for cars and accessories manufactured in South Africa. Throughout the course of the strike, workers were shot at by police and private security guards. Earlier in the month, a smaller union, 16,000 members of the Metal and Electrical Workers Union of South Africa (MEWUSA) in the sector had also joined picket lines. Collectively, the strike has cost NUMSA members some 300 million rand ($20.5 million) in lost wages. 

Compelled by union leadership to accept a paltry deal, the striking workers with the most to lose are now expected to return to work on Monday, while union and corporate leadership can celebrate “a strong partnership … between business and labour,” as SEIFSA CEO Lucio Trentini said in a press release

Agreed to by NUMSA General Secretary Irvin Jim, the new contract includes wage increases of 6 percent on scheduled pay rates for all three years. Workers in higher grades will receive an increase of between 5 percent and 5.5 percent on their scheduled pay rates.

The union previously rejected an even lower wage offer, but the current deal is still significantly below the original demand for an 8-percent wage increase across the board in the first year of the contract, and an increase equal to the rate of inflation plus 2 percent in the subsequent two years. South Africa’s annual inflation is currently around 5 percent.

Though the workers’ original demands included a sliding scale of wages based on inflation, the deal reached by NUMSA includes only fixed rates. If the trend of South Africa’s inflation rates continues upward, workers will surely see their real wages fall.

No wonder the bosses, through SEIFSA, are calling it a “landmark agreement” and are celebrating the workers’ return without having to concede wage increases that would be subject to the fluctuations of the economy.

A press conference with the NUMSA general secretary on Thursday was filled with revolutionary rhetoric, disguising the union bureaucracy’s cynicism and betrayal of the strikers. Despite having already rejected the same offer just days before, Jim announced, “We decided to accept the current 6 percent on minimum despite our clear demand that it must be given on actual rates. We have taken a conscious decision that as a union we will compromise and accept the current offer from SEIFSA.”

While Jim railed against the exploitation by the bosses, it’s clear the interests of the union leadership and the capitalists are closely aligned. South Africa’s president Cyril Ramaphosa, a billionaire businessman, was formerly the leader of the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM).

The strike caused major problems for the auto manufacturing sector in South Africa, which has been slow to recover from the economic impacts of the ongoing Covid crisis. According to the CEO of SEIFSA, Lucio Trentini, affected companies lost 600 million rand ($41 million) due to the strike. BMW’s main vehicle assembly plant in South Africa lost the production of around 700 vehicles.

The auto industry accounts for 5 percent of South Africa’s GDP, and overall the steel and metal industries account for 8 percent.

Just as the strike was starting to have a real impact on capitalist profits, the union leadership capitulated and agreed to less than what the metal workers had demanded. Now, the capitalists are able to avert a potential crisis that would have put real pressure to accept the workers’ demands.  

As global economies recover from pandemic-related losses, the capitalists continue to rake in profit off the backs of workers, who have kept production going throughout the crisis. Workers across the globe are once again recognizing their strategic position in the capitalist chain of production, and demanding higher wages and better working conditions. These strikes in South Africa are connected to a global wave of class struggle that is beginning to rise. In the United States, strikes in a multitude of industries have been reigniting the labor struggle and showing the potential of the working class; just a few days ago, half a million workers in South Korea took part in a one-day general strike. Workers are demanding an end to backbreaking working conditions, scant protections, interminable hours, and poverty-scale pay.

Workers cannot rely on the union bureaucracy to fight to the end for their demands, as the capitulation by the NUMSA leadership illustrates. But that does not mean workers should lose hope, or that there is no other path forward. The rank and file has shown its drive to continue the fight without capitulating. What unions need — from Lancaster, Pennsylvania, where Kellogg workers are striking, to Johannesburg — is rank-and-file leadership and genuine union and workplace democracy.

Facebook Twitter Share

Labor Movement

From Strike to Class Struggle: Building a Fighting Labor Movement in the Ruins of Neoliberalism

Workers are going on strike and millions are resigning from their jobs. But we should not see the current and recent strikes in a vacuum or solely analyze the potential of these strikes by looking at the working class in its workplaces. This is only half the picture. There is a broader rupture, amongst working-class and oppressed people, with what was considered common sense in the neoliberal era.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

November 24, 2021

“We Need to Take Back Our Union”: An IATSE Worker on Organizing for Change

A retired member of IATSE Local 80 describes the transformative process of organizing for union democracy in the wake of a disappointing contract fight.

Left Voice

November 23, 2021
IATSE members marching, carrying a banner that reads "The Union Behind Entertainment"

“We Feel Angry, We Feel Unheard”: IATSE Workers Speak Out on the Betrayal of Their Leadership

Left Voice reached out to IATSE workers and asked for their thoughts on the newly ratified contract. Despite an overwhelming vote to strike and a majority “no” vote, union bureaucracy and undemocratic voting rules betrayed the rank-and-file worker’s demands for better working conditions.

Left Voice

November 22, 2021

Don’t Mourn … Organize! Remembering Joe Hill and His Music

Today marks the day 106 years ago that Joe Hill was executed by the state of Utah. An immigrant, worker, Wobbly, and songwriter, we celebrate his legacy with some of his best songs. His work lives on today, still performed widely with the same witty, fierce lyrics that rail against the capitalist system.

Kimberly Ann

November 19, 2021


Joe Biden in the foreground in black and white, red and blue arrows in the background

The Democratic Party and Capitalism’s Economic Contradictions

The Democratic Party is promising that its spending packages will rejuvenate the economy. And that has helped the party bewitch the Left and dampen mass struggle in the United States. But the economic situation today — riven by fundamental, explosive contradictions — shows that those promises are built on sand, and that we need to reject the Democrats and organize for an independent, revolutionary struggle.

Jason Koslowski

November 27, 2021
A burning building in Minnesota at night. A protester walks by with a flag.

Our Revolutionary Movement in the Twilight of Empire

The uncontested hegemony of U.S. imperialism on the world stage is slowly faltering. The United States needs a coherent revolutionary organization today — united around common answers to the most fundamental questions of the period.

Coco Smyth

November 27, 2021

Germany’s New Government Promises Renewed Attacks on Pensions and Working Hours

Two months after the federal elections, the SPD, the Greens, and the FDP have agreed to form a new government. It promises some reforms, but also new neoliberal measures and increased militarism.

Von Marco Helmbrecht

November 26, 2021
Polynesian president Édouard Fritch at a press conference on November 24

Government Inflexibility Provokes General Strike in French Polynesia

For more than a week, especially in the Caribbean, France’s “overseas territories” have seen a wave of mobilizations against the government. On Wednesday, it spread to French Polynesia, in the Pacific.

Antoine Bordas

November 26, 2021