Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Fed Up with AOC? Meet Myriam Bregman

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is known around the world as a socialist in the U.S. Congress. Yet she has disappointed supporters on the Left by voting to fund ICE and the Israeli war machine. Are all elected officials going to betray us? We compare AOC’s record to that of Myriam Bregman, the socialist congressmember from Argentina.

Nathaniel Flakin

October 27, 2021
Facebook Twitter Share

Fox News and Donald Trump absolutely hate Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez — yet she is not as radical as they seem to think she is. AOC’s voting record has disappointed supporters on the Left. Some might think that any socialist elected to Congress is bound to betray their left-wing promises.

But wait! On the opposite end of the American double continent, a socialist congressperson in Argentina is also making waves. Myriam Bregman is a representative of the Workers Left Front — Unity (FIT-U), and she is currently running for a seat in the national congress for the City of Buenos Aires.

How do AOC and Bregman compare in ten political categories?

Spoiler alert: AOC disappoints. However, this isn’t about AOC as an individual. It is about her political project of working within the Democratic Party to win reforms. Bregman in Argentina is part of a radically different project — a revolutionary socialist force that aims to topple capitalism. So the real question is: how do these two opposing strategies compare?

Salary

As a member of Congress, AOC earns US$174,000 per year. She is not a millionaire, as some right-wing critics have claimed, but like any politician in the U.S. Congress, she enjoys an extremely comfortable lifestyle.

Bregman refuses to take anything more than the salary of a teacher. Concretely, she takes just 60,000 pesos per month (573 U.S. dollars). Members of the Buenos Aires legislature earn over 260,000 pesos per month after taxes (around 2,500 U.S. dollars). So Bregman donates more than 75% of that money to a strike fund that directly supports workers’ struggles.

Palestine

When the U.S. Congress voted on $1 billion to fund the Israeli war machine, on top of billions of dollars in military aid every year, AOC could have voted “no.” Instead, she voted “present.” She had called Israel an “apartheid state” — and yet didn’t want to get in the way of supporting the occupation regime.

Bregman, in contrast, has been steadfast in her support of the Palestinian struggle for liberation. As a result, right-wing forces have accused her of antisemitism — a common slander against anyone who is critical of the Israeli government.

There is a certain irony to this, as Bregman is also among Argentina’s most prominent politicians of Jewish origin. Right-wing politicians have also carried out antisemitic attacks against her. She responded, “The ruling classes have done this many times: using antisemitism to distract from who are the real enemies,” of working people.

Military

AOC voted to give $1.5 trillion to the U.S. military as part of a two-year budget resolution. The military uses this money to enact violence and destruction around the world.

Bregman, like all the other representatives of the FIT-U, sticks to socialist principles: “not one man and not one cent to militarism!” This means always voting against the budget for the capitalist government. As a human rights lawyer, Bregman took a leading role in pressing charges against military officers for their crimes against humanity during the dictatorship. 

Borders

AOC has voted to fund ICE. This allows a Gestapo-like police force to terrorize immigrants. Back when Trump was in office, AOC used to criticize the concentration camps for immigrant children. Now, with Biden in the White House, AOC has said that kids need to be put in cages.

Bregman defends the old-school socialist call for open borders. This is not about words, either: Bregman joins protests by immigrant workers against racist police, for living wages, and for decent housing.

Internationalism

AOC gave tacit support to the coup attempts in Venezuela. While Trump was hatching plots to remove the Venezuelan government, AOC refused to condemn these imperialist machinations, instead saying she would “defer to caucus leadership” — i.e. support the Democratic Party, which also supported the coup plans. She similarly met with supporters of the coup government in Bolivia.

Bregman gave support to the mass uprisings in Ecuador and Chile against pro-imperialist governments. Bregman’s party never gave political support to the governments of Nicolás Maduro or Hugo Chávez, but was even more forceful in condemning any international interference in Latin America. This was not limited to words: socialist politicians spoke at rallies and were in the front lines of solidarity demonstrations at the U.S. embassy.

Class Enemy

AOC famously went to the Met Gala to rub elbows with billionaires. As if this would make it any less despicable, her dress featured the tepid reformist slogan: “Tax the Rich.” When criticized for her choice of affiliation, AOC tried to paint herself as a victim of sexism.

Bregman, like all the representatives of the Workers Left Front, refuses to attend any closed-door meetings with representatives of the exploiters. All her work in Parliament is in full public view.

Career

According to rumors, AOC is planning a run for the Senate — that is one explanation for why she chose to betray the Palestinian cause. Capitalist politicians make a career out of serving in Congress, and most of them become very wealthy in the process.

Bregman had a seat in the national Congress for 1.5 years. Then she resigned to make way for other representatives of the Workers Left Front — all the FIT-U’s representatives rotate like this. She then spent four years as a legislator in the City of Buenos Aires.

Cops

AOC does photo ops with the NYPD — the same police force that beats and murders AOC’s voters.

Bregman, as a revolutionary socialist, is a relentless opponent of police and their so-called “unions.” She calls for workers’ self-defense and the abolition of the police.

Class Independence

AOC is formally a member of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA). But does that mean anything? The DSA has zero influence over how she votes. Any  “accountability” is limited to an AOC staffer calling people in Queens once a month. AOC does not represent her socialist base — instead, she represents the Democratic wing of the U.S. capitalist class.

Bregman is a leading member of the Party of Socialist Workers (PTS) which is part of the Workers Left Front — Unity (FIT-U). She has worked for decades to build up a revolutionary socialist organization with deep roots in workplaces, schools and universities, and neighborhoods. Bregman’s votes are not based on her whims — they represent the organization that put her in office. 

Conclusion

Comparing AOC vs. Bregman in ten categories, the result is… 10 to 0 for Bregman.

This is not because Bregman is a better person than AOC or a more honest socialist. Rather, it is because Bregman is part of a revolutionary socialist party, whereas AOC is part of a capitalist party. “Socialists” in the Democratic Party will always betray their voters. The only alternative is to build up a party of and for working people.

Facebook Twitter Share

Nathaniel Flakin

Nathaniel is a freelance journalist and historian from Berlin. He is on the editorial board of Left Voice and our German sister site Klasse Gegen Klasse. Nathaniel, also known by the nickname Wladek, has written a biography of Martin Monath, a Trotskyist resistance fighter in France during World War II, which has appeared in German, in English, and in French. He is on the autism spectrum.

Instagram

Ideas & Debates

No to NATO Tanks in Ukraine, Let’s Fight the Escalation!

Left Voice and our comrades in Germany issue a joint statement against NATO sending tanks to Ukraine. We call on the working class to organize against this reactionary war which continues to escalate.

Left Voice

January 31, 2023
Detroit socialist activist Tristan Taylor at a protest during 2020.

First We Mourn, Then We Organize: A Letter to Weary Black Organizers Who Have Had Enough

Tyre Nichols, and all victims of police brutality, must be mourned. But we can't stop fighting or give in to despair — we have to build an independent political party that clashes with the capitalists physically, politically, and ideologically.

Tristan Taylor

January 29, 2023
All That's Left, the podcast from Left Voice.

#AllThatsLeftPod: Two Years of U.S. Imperialism under Biden

In this episode of the podcast, we discuss the terrain of U.S. imperialism under the first two years of the Biden presidency, and the importance of an internationalist, anti-imperialist Left.

Left Voice

January 24, 2023

Reprint: Solidarity with the Movement to Stop Cop City and Defend the Weelaunee Forest

Left Voice endorses the statement released by the autonomous movement to Defend The Atlanta Forest. We republish the statement below and echo the movement's call for solidarity with their movement.

Left Voice

January 23, 2023

MOST RECENT

A horizontal testing scantron with almost all of the bubbles filled in

The Changes to AP African American Studies Are “Absolutely Political”: A Former College Board Worker Speaks Out

A former College Board worker explains how the company's "apolitical" pedagogical approaches privilege right wing ideas, even as the right wing accuses them of spreading "wokeism."

Jess DuBois

February 4, 2023

The Strike Is Our Most Powerful Weapon, We Need to Use It against the Police!

Workers have the opportunity and ability to shut down the system. This is why Democrats, Republicans, and even the Squad broke the strike of the railroad workers. If we use our workplaces as organizing tools against racism and police murder, we can build the power to take control and shut them down! 

Julia Wallace

February 3, 2023

Dispatches from the Picket Lines: All Out for the Temple Graduate Workers Strike

A Temple faculty member reports.

Jason Koslowski

February 3, 2023

Massive Looting of Public Resources at Stake in District Detroit Redevelopment Scheme

Billionaire developers in Detroit have proposed capturing almost one billion dollars in public money to fund their newest project. The deal is far from sealed, but organized community opposition will be necessary to prevent approvals from sailing through.

Rita Singer

February 3, 2023